The seventh member of the Tribunal Constitucional (TC) was elected by Congress on 14 November in an express session without debate. He is Pedro Hernández and he replaces Augusto Ferrero Costa who has died. One of four finalists, he was ratified by 99 votes to 15 with seven abstentions. Those voting in favour included Fuerza Popular, Renovación Popular and Perú Libre. Those who opposed his appointment came mainly from the centre-left-Cambio Democrático-Juntos por el Perú grouping.

Hernández’s appointment looks likely further to bolster the right-of-centre control over the TC. As readers will recall, the TC voted – albeit not by the required quorum of five – to release Alberto Fujimori from jail. The TC has the last word when it comes to interpretation of constitutional matters, though its supremacy in that case was challenged by the ruling from the Inter-American Court on Human Rights, which objected to Fujimori’s release.

Congress voted in six new members of the TC in May 2022, several renowned for their right-wing sympathies. The method by which they were voted in was criticised at the time for the lack of transparency and debate. Some called it a ‘stitch-up’ (repartija) designed to strengthen the hand of Peru’s hard right.

Hernández was previously an advisor at the ONPE when the rules governing party financing were made more flexible. At the time he also was a candidate for the TC, but his candidacy was removed after allegations emerged of his having beaten up his by-then ex-wife on two occasions. Since leaving the ONPE he worked as an advisor to Gustavo Gutiérrez Ticse until December 2022, one of the justices who backed Fujimori’s release.

The way in which the ruling was made on the Fujimori case has been strongly criticised by Manuel Monteagudo, one of the two TC justices not to be consulted on the case. In an interview in La República he made clear his view that this was not just a procedural issue but a matter of substance and that it could not be adjudicated by just three of the then six TC justices. He has called for the ruling to be nullified.

Walter Albán, the former ombudsman, has also raised his voice in alarm, calling Hernández’s appointment “a farse” and part of the plan to protect those in office in the legislature. “I think this nomination is like that of the ombudsman (Josué Gutiérrez), it will work to the advantage of delinquents.”