12 May saw the official confirmation in El Peruano of the election of the six new members of the Constitutional Tribunal selected two days earlier. They were sworn in the following day on 13 May in a session that was neither preannounced nor transmitted. The procedure for electing the six was widely criticised for its lack of transparency or debate. Most of the six are noted for their conservativism, some for their links with parties of the far right. The TC plays a key role in determining what is constitutional in Peru and what is not.
The method by which the new justices were selected was criticised as a ‘stitch up’ (repartija) involving an accord between the Cerronista majority of Peru Libre on the left and most of the far-right parties. Centrist and centre-left politicians in Congress loudly protested at the way in which party leaders had connived to prevent any debate on the merits (or otherwise) of each candidate. The 857-page document from the Comptroller’s office providing background on each candidate was also widely redacted. Members of the press were excluded from the session.
María del Carmen Alva, the president of Congress who appears to have validated the procedure adopted, described the election as “an historic day for the whole of Peru”, claiming that it was “an example of how we can work in consensus”.
The new members include Francisco Morales Saravia and Luis Gutiérrez, both known for their close ties to the Fujimorista Fuerza Popular party. Luz Pacheco Zerga, the only woman selected, is known for her links to Opus Dei. Manuel Monteagudo and César Ochoa are practicing lawyers with connections to the Catholic University (PUCP). Helder Domínguez was originally excluded from the selection but was included only at the insistence of the special appointments commission in Congress.
The president of the TC is Augusto Ferrero, the only member of the old tribunal not to have been replaced. He supported the controversial decision that upheld the pardon for jailed former president Alberto Fujimori.
As we have repeatedly pointed out, the TC is the ultimate voice in interpreting the constitution. It has played a crucial role on many issues in mediating disputes between the executive power and the legislature. The conservative orientation of the new TC will add to the handicaps facing the Castillo administration as it faces repeated attempts to defend itself against attacks from a far right which has never fully accepted the president’s narrow victory in the 2021 elections. The TC is likely to block attempts by the government to put the issue of constitutional rewriting to a popular referendum.
In a statement responding to criticisms about how the new TC members were elected, the Inter-American Commission of Human Rights said: “In line with inter-American standards, the whole process of electing members of higher courts should be based on the merits, capacity and integrity of candidates so as not to place their independence at risk”. The congressional commission which selected candidates failed to engage with an international group of jurists which had expressed concern about the selection process.
In protest at the way the Cerronista majority in Congress handled the election of new TC members, ten members of Perú Libre (PL) have since announced the formation of a further breakaway party, independent of Vladimir Cerrón’s leadership. Most of them belong to the so-called ‘bloque magisterial’ which is close to Castillo. The original PL grouping has now split three ways. This latest split makes Fuerza Popular the single largest party in Congress.
Recent Comments