With the vote in Congress on dismissing members of the Jurado Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) postponed for the time being, a majority in the legislature approved a number of laws designed to reinforce its privileges, protect its members from accusations of corruption, and promote the interests of party hierarchies. The current legislature ended on 15 December with the last few days seeing a flurry of initiatives.
The proposed vote on the JNJ, which is responsible for selecting and dismissing judges as well as the leaders of Peru’s electoral authorities, is widely viewed as a serious attack on democratic institutions.
On 14 December, Congress voted by 89 to 14 with two abstentions to limit severely the use of plea bargaining (colaboración eficaz). The legislation specifies a maximum of eight months during which an application for plea bargaining can be accepted, extendable to twelve months in exceptional cases. The use of plea bargaining has been widespread in recent years, notably during the investigation into the Lava Jato scandal which revealed the scale of corruption at the highest levels of government.
The Boluarte administration had opposed the law put forward by Congress, arguing that a limit of 36 months was reasonable and that the eight-month limit would represent a severe obstacle to investigating highly complex cases such as Lava Jato. The administration had returned the law to Congress for further discussion, but now Congress has had the final word.
Congress also approved legislation on 14 December that removes the need for parties to hold open primaries in the selection of presidential candidates. This will strengthen the scope for party leaders simply to appoint their own favoured candidates. Since 2019, parties have been obliged to ratify candidates through an open contest in which all citizens can take part. However, such elections, known as PASO, have not so far been held.
The law was approved by 74 votes in favour, 36 against and with twelve abstentions. The legislation suggests three methods for selecting candidates: by citizen participation on the basis of lists of voters previously registered with the parties; through the voting of party members/militants; and through voting by delegates.
On the JNJ issue, the congressional leadership agreed at the last minute on 15 December to reprogramme the discussion to allow members of the JNJ to prepare their defence. The vote follows the JNJ’s suspension of Patricia Benavides as the chief public prosecutor (Fiscal de la Nación) and is widely viewed as a reprisal. Benavides was replaced on a temporary basis by Juan Carlos Villena who has pledged to carry out a thorough reorganisation of the Ministerio Público.
The same day, Congress approved a resolution requiring the Justice Commission, within ten working days, to investigate members of the JNJ over their role in suspending Benavides.
Meanwhile, the Congress has launched an attack on the inter-American system of human rights. On 15 December, by 69 votes to 37 with two abstentions, it approved the creation of a commission to come up with “suggestions” for the reform of the system. If the Organization of American States fails to implement these within 180 days, the Peruvian state would consider denouncing the American Convention on Human Rights.
The move was approved by members from Fuerza Popular, Renovación Popular, Alianza para el Progreso and other parties on the right that objected to criticisms from the Inter-American Court to the release of former president Alberto Fujimori from jail. Several members of Congress have previously expressed the view that Peru should withdraw from the inter-American human rights system.
Recent Comments