Following a highly controversial ruling of the Constitutional Tribunal (TC), government authorities released Alberto Fujimori from detention on 6 December. They did so in defiance of an order by the Inter-American Court on Human Rights (IACHR), a move that puts Peru on a collision course with the international legal system.
The decision of the TC was taken by three magistrates, without notifying at least two other members. All three had close sympathies with the Fujimorista cause and the right-wing parties in Congress that have long pushed for Fujimori’s release; chief among them Fuerza Popular, the party led by Fujimori’s daughter Keiko.
Manuel Monteagudo, one of the magistrates not consulted, argues that decisions of the IACHR are legally binding on Peru and that consideration of the IACHR’s demands should have involved all, not just three TC members.
Congress appointed six of the seven members of the TC last May. Their election was criticised at the time for lacking transparency and proper parliamentary debate. Most of the new members were noted for their conservatism, some with links to the far right. Their number included the three who voted for Fujimori’s release: Francisco Morales, Luis Gutiérrez and Luz Pacheco.
Fujimori has been in jail since his conviction in 2009 to 25 years imprisonment for corruption and human rights crimes. His release has been demanded insistently on account of the former president’s age and his alleged infirmity. The IACHR proscribes the issue of pardons for what it sees as gross violations of human rights for which Fujimori was found guilty over the Barrios Altos and La Cantuta killings.
The decision to pardon Fujimori was originally taken by then president Pedro Pablo Kuczynski at the end of 2017. This appeared at the time to be part of a shady deal with Fujimori’s son, Kenji, to prevent Kuczynski’s imminent impeachment by Congress. According to Kuczynski’s memoir, he took the decision on the advice of Pope Francis on a visit to the Vatican. He was forced to resign months later.
Responding to the news of Fujimori’s release, Cardinal Archbishop Pedro Barreto described it as an “insult” (“cachetada”) to the country that provoked “indignation”.
Following Kuzcynski’s decision on Fujimori’s pardon, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled that such a pardon conflicted with international legal norms. Last week, anticipating the TC’s decision, the IACHR ordered Peru to provide information by 6 December over adherence to its earlier mandate preventing Fujimori’s release.
The decision to free Fujimori has met with strong opposition both in Peru and internationally. For several experts it threatens to further isolate the country diplomatically and place in question Peru’s adherence to international juridical standards. These could include investment rulings by the World Bank’s International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID). It may also put at further jeopardy Peru’s hopes to join the OECD in 2026. The weakness of the rule of law and the extent of corruption have not gone unnoticed at the OECD.
It remains to be seen whether Fujimori’s release will involve forgiving him the debt he owes to the Peruvian state. Nothing has been paid while he was in jail. The amount is thought to total 27.5 million soles (some US$7.1 million), but when interest payments are added it is reckoned to be nearly double that at 57 million soles.
The Boluarte government’s decision to release Fujimori adds further fuel to the flames of domestic opposition. Protest marches had already been programmed for three days (7-9 December) for the anniversary of former president Pedro Castillo’s abrupt removal from office and his replacement by Boluarte. Opponents demand Boluarte’s resignation, the closure of Congress and the convening of a constituent assembly to rewrite Fujimori’s 1993 constitution.
In previous days the Boluarte administration announced drastic penalties against those using violent methods on demonstrations.
For its part, the Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos asks the question whether a country can call itself democratic when key institutions – namely the public prosecution service, the ombudsman’s office, the Congress, the presidency and now the TC – take decisions on the basis of “I want therefore I can”. It also maintains that the pardon offered by Kuczynski was “a product of a corrupt negotiation which traded Fujimori’s pardon for votes to prevent Kuczynski’s impeachment.
Fujimori’s release was widely welcomed by Fuerza Popular and other parties on the right. “Finally, justice and humanity have imposed themselves,” Keiko Fujimori is quoted as saying.
Responding to Fujimori’s release, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights issued a statement saying that this was “in contravention to the State’s international obligations and non-compliant with the orders issued by the Court”. This was in virtue of Peru’s ratification of the American Convention on Human Rights. According to Carlos Rivera of the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) quoted by El País, it could lead to a denunciation against Peru in the Organization of American States (OAS).
Recent Comments