First the ombudsman, then the Constitutional Tribunal, now the heads of the three electoral bodies; the far right in Congress – led on by the fujimoristas in Fuerza Popular (FP) – are determined to have their hands on the levers of power well in advance of the 2026 elections. Legislation is being considered in the Constitution Commission to put to the plenary of Congress before the present legislature closes on 15 June.
This week the Constitution Commission also approved bills that seek to amend the constitution by abolishing the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) and change the way in which the leaders of Peru’s three electoral institutions are chosen. The Constitution Commission is presided over by the FP stalwart, Martha Moyano.
As readers will recall, the JNJ has been involved in a long-running battle to remove Patricia Benavides the suspended chief public prosecutor from office, a key ally of the far right in Congress. It finally managed to achieve this last month. The JNJ is responsible for the appointment and dismissal of judges and public prosecutors as well as the heads of the Oficina Nacional de Procesos Electorales (ONPE) and, the Registro Nacional de Identificación Nacional y Estado Civil (Reniec). The ONPE is responsible for the administration of elections while Reniec administers the register of eligible voters.
For its part the five-member Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE) is formed by an ex officio magistrate of the Supreme Court who acts as its president; a member of the Junta de Fiscales Supremos; a representative selected by the Colegio de Abogados de Lima among its members; a representative elected by the deans of public university law faculties among their number; and one elected similarly by the deans of private universities. The JNE is responsible for confirming the results of elections and resolving disputes.
According to legislation also being promoted by FP, the president of the JNE would be chosen by its other members.
The Constitution Commission has also come up with proposals to change Article 99 of the constitution so that the heads of all three organisations can be subjected to constitutional accusations in Congress. Currently they enjoy autonomy from the legislature.
According to the Constitution Commission’s plans, the JNJ would be replaced by an Escuela Nacional de la Magistratura which would be given the task of training future judges and prosecutors, a function currently undertaken by the Academia de la Magistratura. The heads of both the JNJ and the Escuela would be appointed by the restored Senate, again eliminating their independence of Congress. This has been described by Aldo Vásquez, until recently a member of the JNJ, as “absolutely irresponsible” by undermining the autonomy of judges and politicising the electoral institutions.
For his part, Fernando Tuesta, a former head of ONPE and prominent student of Peru’s political system, has described the attempt to abolish the JNJ and to put the nomination of the heads of the ONPE and Reniec in the hands of the Senate as an “absurdity” (“despropósito”) that would further concentrate political power in the hands of Congress. He went on to say that “what this Congress is doing is an abuse of power since, as it can make laws and agree to change the constitution, it can do things that contravene the spirit of democracy”.
As always, Carlin has a good take on all this.
An international observer mission this week warned of the deterioration of institutions in Peru, specifically the threat to the JNJ. The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights has also expressed concern about “interference in the functions of authorities whose mandates are essential for the preservation of democracy”.
Recent Comments