On 22 May, the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ), the body charged with judicial appointments, voted to dismiss Patricia Benavides, the already-suspended chief public prosecutor who is at the heart of accusations of corruption within the Ministerio Público (MP). This represents a serious reverse for many right-wing members of Congress who had sought to restore Benavides to her position in the MP when her six-month suspension ends on 6 June. It is also a blow for President Dina Boluarte.

All five current members of the JNJ voted for dismissal, thus achieving the necessary quorum. The two other members of the JNJ were unable to vote, having been removed from office by Congress. The JNJ also voted to remove from office, Benavides’ sister, Enma, a senior judge, for allegedly receiving bribes from a person accused of drug trafficking. Known as ‘La Doña’, she had been accused of using her position to free a number of drug traffickers.

The pretext for Patricia Benavides’ removal was her role in removing a senior prosecutor, Bersabeth Revilla, from a case involving Enma, allegedly on the grounds of failure to meet efficiency targets. These grounds, it was shown, were spurious. In the view of the JNJ, Patricia Benavides’ conduct constituted no less than four “very grave” infractions.

Benavides is also separately accused of leading a “criminal organisation” within the MP, a case currently before Congress. She was originally suspended as chief public prosecutor for six months on 6 December and replaced on an interim basis by Juan Carlos Villena.

Before her suspension, Benavides was actively involved in attempts to get Congress to remove all seven members of the JNJ. The accusations against Benavides stemmed, in part, from the plea bargain evidence supplied by her former assistant at the MP, Jaime Villanueva. Villanueva recounted how Benavides sought to remove a predecessor as chief public prosecutor, Zoraida Avalos, from all public office. He also gave evidence concerning how Benavides sought to influence the appointment by Congress of a new ombudsman and to sack the members of the JNJ.

Established procedures at the JNJ offer both Benavides sisters the right of appeal to the same five sitting members. It seems unlikely that they will change their minds. The two can also take their case to the Constitutional Tribunal, but this would take time.

Assuming any appeal is dismissed, the Junta de Fiscales Supremos will proceed to electing a new chief public prosecutor from among its ranks. The Junta is made up of Villena, Pablo Sánchez and Delia Espinoza, with Avalos now returning to its ranks following a ruling by the judiciary.

A likely outcome is that Villena be appointed chief public prosecutor on a permanent basis. So far, he has taken an active role in trying clean up corruption within the MP.

Benavides’ removal will also be bad news for President Dina Boluarte who faces the threat of investigation by the public prosecution service over the Rolex affair and other matters.