On 18 September, President Martín Vizcarra survived, by a substantial margin, the attempt to impeach him. Members of Congress voted 32 in favour, 78 against, and with 15 abstentions, to enable the president to continue in office. The scale of the defeat for those seeking to remove Vizcarra is a further rebuff to the legislature and a major victory for the president.

The vote followed a turbulent week which had begun with the initiation of impeachment proceedings on 11 September, to which Vizcarra had countered with an appeal to the Constitutional Tribunal (TC).

The threat of impeachment deflated as the week went on as it became clearer that it was part of a premeditated plan – a sort of constitutional coup – by some leaders in the legislature to replace Vizcarra in office with the president of Congress, Manuel Merino. Not only had Merino made approaches to the heads of the army and navy not to oppose the ploy, but it became clear that he had already begun to plan his cabinet.

In his speech to Congress on 18 September defending himself against impeachment, Vizcarra claimed that the only illegality committed was the clandestine recording made by one of his team and then passed on to Congressman Edgar Alarcón, on the so-called Swing affair. The president said the attempt to remove him was particularly inopportune given the grave health crisis facing the country. “Peru cannot be held back by the content of audio tapes of zero validity” he said, “the management of the pandemic and the economic reactivation cannot be placed in suspense”.

The executive’s previous appeal to the TC sought to block the attempt to remove Vizcarra. In an emergency session on 17 September, the tribunal rejected a cautionary measure (medida cautelar) which would have halted the process to unseat Vizcarra. On the other hand, it decided that it fell within its remit to decide on the actual meaning of what the phrase used in Article 113 as a pretext for impeachment, ‘incapacidad moral permanente’ (‘permanent moral incapacity’). This is one of five reasons for the removal of a sitting president from office. Further, the TC voted down the suggestion that the numbers required to approve the removal of a president should be increased from 87 (two thirds of the Congress) to 104 (four fifths).

The Peruvian constitution, adopted in 1993 and designed by the then government of Alberto Fujimori, contains a ‘double lock’. The president can dismiss Congress and force new legislative elections when the Congress fails to uphold a vote of confidence in the cabinet twice in a five-year term. The Congress, in turn, can vote to remove a president under specified circumstances, one of which is his or her ‘permanent moral or physical incapacity’. The president cannot dissolve Congress in his or her last year in office.

The last week has seen further information appear about the role played by Karem Roca, the former presidential assistant who recorded conversations about Vizcarra’s dealings with Richard ‘Swing’, and that of Alarcón, the congressman who blew the whistle, thus provoking the constitutional crisis.

Roca’s public statements about alleged corruption by Vizcarra have been effectively proven false, while Alarcón, formerly comptroller of the republic, faces accusations of corruption of his own when he occupied the office. Roca had alleged that José Domingo Pérez, the public prosecutor leading investigations into the Lava Jato affair, had been involved in protecting Vizcarra when the latter was governor of Moquegua. This appears to be untrue.