The capture of state institutions by the far right took a significant step forwards this week with the vote in the Permanent Commission in Congress approving a proposal by the Sub-Commission on Constitutional Accusations to get rid of all the current members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ). A vote will be held in the plenary session on 6 March. The JNJ, which appoints judges, prosecutors and electoral authorities, has long been a target for parties in Congress. The executive has complained that this will tilt the balance of power even further in the direction of the legislature, currently dominated by parties of the far right.
Readers will recall that it was the JNJ which suspended Patricia Benavides as the chief public prosecutor back in December. Benavides, it became clear, was at the centre of a network by which members of Congress sought to influence decisions pending in the judiciary.
The grounds for suspension of JNJ members had been their decision back in 2020 that one of their number, Inés Tello, could remain in post despite having reached the age of 75. It was argued that she was under this age when elected and could therefore serve out her five-year mandate. Samuel Abad, a prominent constitutional expert present in the proceedings, cited in his defence of this Articles 155 and 156 of the constitution.
If the suspension is approved in the plenary on 6 March – as seems more than likely – it will enable the Congress to appoint new members of the JNJ more amenable to their interests. In the last two years, Congress has been able to gain control over other key institutions of the state, notably the Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría del Pueblo) and the all-important Constitutional Tribunal.
The decision in Congress met with criticism from President Dina Boluarte. In a press conference on 28 February, she called for “reflection” on the part of members of Congress. “I believe that in a democratic country, under the rule of law, we have to have a balance between the powers [of the state]” she is quoted as saying.
Beyond the executive, there has been widespread condemnation of the support of the Commission for removing the current JNJ members. For many, it is a further dangerous step towards forms of authoritarian government reminiscent of the Fujimori era in the 1990s when the government was able to manipulate the judiciary and other state institutions for its own ends.
Internationally, the move is likely to have significant repercussions, especially within the Inter-American system of human rights. Already there are moves for Peru to be reclassified in terms of its adherence to international norms. Peru’s Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL), in a session on judicial risks in Latin America, has formally requested that the Inter-American Commission reclassify Peru in this respect, placing it in the same category as Nicaragua and Venezuela.
The delegation of civil society organisations, of which the IDL forms part, pointed to problems in a range of Peru’s institutions, notably in the JNJ but also with respect to the TC, the Ministerio Público and the Defensoría.
The session also included Margaret Satterthwaite, the UN’s special rapporteur who last October expressed her concern for the autonomy of the JNJ from congressional control.
Recent Comments