The PSG webinar was held on 16 April and featured Dan Collyns, Lima correspondent for The Guardian and BBC; José Víctor Salcedo, a journalist in Cuzco; and Mirtha Vásquez, the former prime minister and candidate for the Senate. Upwards of 66 people attended the webinar. If you would like to watch it in its entirety, use this link.

Dan Collyns began by recounting the latest on the count, with less than 8,000 votes separating Roberto Sánchez (in the lead) from Rafael López Aliaga. The count had been the subject of accusations of fraud, based in part on the late delivery of election materials by ONPE. He highlighted the “vulgar language” used by López Aliaga in denigrating Sánchez and those voting for him.

José Víctor Salcedo provided a regional perspective, stressing the sympathy for a pro-Castillo candidate throughout the south. He saw Fujimorismo as a persistent and organised political force, albeit less strong than previously. The pro-Sanchez vote reflected the feeling that the south had been abandoned by policy makers in Lima and that it was a protest vote against the “mafioso pact” that had dominated decision making.

Mirtha Vásquez argued that the election result was a product of ten years of policy making in which institutional changes had been geared to facilitating re-election of incumbents. 87 of the 130 members were seeking re-election, either to the Senate or Chamber of Deputies. People, she argued, had voted out of a spirit of “revenge”, with larger participation than in earlier elections. With all the fragmentation, 70% had voted neither for Fujimori nor López Aliaga. She expressed concern for the allegations of fraud, the degree of polarisation between “populist” options, and that the “opposition” vote would not translate into a majority in Congress.

In a second round of interventions, Vásquez went on to outline the two scenarios: either a conservative alliance with power consolidated between Fuerza Popular and Renovación Popular, or a polarised stand-off between populists of the left and right. She saw neither as good options.

José Víctor recounted how most people in the south would never vote for Fujimori and saw the ousting of Castillo as a victim of a right-wing plot. They were less concerned about the “populism” of Sánchez and did not buy the narrative of him representing “communism” or “terrorism”. Fujimori had a much higher rejection rate in Cuzco that Sánchez. He saw Sánchez seeking to build a coalition with other parties if he goes forward to the second round. He argued that “Peru is living through a very marked social fracture”.

In the Q and A, Mirtha was asked why the Senate was so important. She answered that this was because it could not be dissolved, while the president can still be impeached. It has the power to repeal norms and remove key authorities from office. She feared that the election would result in a “ultra-right” majority.  The restoration of the Senate was designed, she said, to prevent a left-wing president from pursuing radical reforms. She was also asked how future fragmentation was to be avoided, answering that the rules need to be changed, especially the introduction of compulsory primaries.

Dan was asked whether Peru fell into the pattern in Latin America of a shift to the right. He argued that while violent crime was a common feature and that Fujimori, López Aliaga and others had used this to vent a ‘law and order’ narrative, Peru was not like El Salvador, and that the shift to the right was not supported across the country.

José Víctor was asked why Ricardo Belmont had done so well in Cuzco. He thought it was the result of successful social media campaigning among the youngest voters who saw Jorge Nieto and Alfonso López Chau as less attractive options.