The issue of the conservation of the Amazonian rainforest and its natural resources has long been a point of contention between the Peruvian state and indigenous peoples, with the latter highly critical of the lack of interest and effectiveness of the former. Two examples, one in the Madre de Dios region and the other in Loreto, illustrate some of the difficulties and possibilities.

The Amarakaeri Communal Reserve in Madre de Dios plays a key role in linking the Manu National Park to its north and the Tambopata National Reserve and the Bahuaja Sonene National Park to its south, comprising one of the Amazon’s biodiversity hot spots.

The Amarakaeri Reserve is a protected area jointly administered by the Executor of the Administrative Contract (ECA Amarakaeri), representing the indigenous communities within the reserve, and the state’s National Protected Areas Service (SERNANP), a dependency of the Ministry for the Environment (Minam). It is generally considered to be one of the more effective conservation projects.

Nevertheless, the most recent report of the MAAP, which regularly monitors the state of the rainforest, shows that between 2001 and 2023 the reserve lost 19,978 hectares of forest in its buffer zone. This was due mainly to illegal gold mining, the expansion of coca cultivation, the construction of unplanned roads, and the building of clandestine air strips for drug trafficking.

For decades indigenous communities in the Loreto region have waged campaigns against successive oil companies and the state to obtain remediation for the environmental damage created by oil drilling and extraction. After prolonged negotiations, in 2013 agreement was reached for the state to assume responsibility and take remedial action.

Since then, an alliance of indigenous organisations from the Pastaza, Corrientes, Tigre and Marañón river valleys, grouped together in the PUINAMUDT internet platform, has been agitating and negotiating for the promised remediation to be implemented. The rehabilitation plans were finally elaborated and have been under evaluation for the last four years by the Ministry of Energy and Mines (Minem).

PUINAMUDT has placed on its website an assessment of the plans and committed resources, noting that, for the first time in Peru’s history, rehabilitation plans have been prepared and approved with full participation by the affected indigenous peoples. However, they claim that, although the energy sector at the beginning was prepared to assign funds (up to 400 million soles – an important commitment but still short of the projected costs of rehabilitation), the Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas (MEF) is withholding funding, claiming budgetary constraints.

Nevertheless, experience has shown that it is possible for the state and indigenous peoples to participate technically and politically in spaces of environmental and social co-management.