Days before International Women’s Day on 8 March, the congressional commission for women and family affairs approved a bill aimed at changing the name of the Ministry for Women and Vulnerable Populations (MIMP) to the Ministry for Families and Vulnerable Populations. This, along with other reversals of women’s and other human rights, has been geminating for a while now. It would seem that the problems facing women of harassment, rape and other kinds of aggression are no longer of such importance for those in Congress. According to the Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría del Pueblo) in 2023 there were no less than 5,184 complaints arising from assaults of one kind or another. Of these, 41% concerned adults and 59% children and adolescents.
What is going on that such alarming figures are not being taken seriously and that we are witnessing such initiatives as changing the name of the ministry, thus minimising the salience of the violence and abuses suffered by women? Why are such proposals being advanced and to what end? Fear, intimidation and the lack of access to justice seem to be a formula for detaining and reversing the already insufficient advances made by feminist and human rights organisations over the past 30 years.
The witch-hunt appears to be moving forward again – that is if it ever stopped – on the part of those who occupy positions of power within the state. Remember in the Middle Ages and even in the modern period the sort of response that met those who defended the scientific revolution, humanism and the modern state. It would appear that this war continues through to our days when women are assassinated, used as battle fodder, harassed and downgraded with respect to their capacities.
Although we are in the fourth wave of feminism, we lack many of the tools to activate people’s awareness and to reveal the true dimensions of women’s rights. Just a few days ago Netflix screened a film called ‘La Manada’ (‘The Pack’). This tells the story of a victim of events that divided Spain into two sectors: on the one hand those who considered that a young woman, apparently under the influence of alcohol and drugs, was sexually abused by five men known as ‘the pack’ and who brazenly declared that the woman had consented willingly; on the other those that consider that the rape of a woman bears no justification whatsoever.
What is interesting here is the debate among Spanish citizens on this. In the first instance the law cast the aggressors as having committed a crime of ‘sexual abuse’ but not rape. Following this there was a wave of protest involving thousands, if not millions of activists who defended the victim under the hashtag ‘Yositecreo’ (‘I believe you’). This further embittered the debate, with those defending La Manada repeating the machista and patriarchal narrative that ‘she was drunk’ … ‘she knew what she was doing’ … ‘what was a decent girl doing in the street late at night’. In turn, civil society groups using social media rallied to protect her and come to her defence. Finally, the High Court judged it to be a case of rape, even managing to change the penalties envisaged under the constitution for cases such as these.
This reminds me of the occasion when, in Peru, they tried to modify the Plan for Comprehensive Reparations (PIR). The PIR came about thanks to the recommendations made by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. It aimed to provide reparations for the victims of violence during the years between May 1980 and November 2000. The modification sought to include not just the victims of violence as such but also the victims of sexual assault, including those sterilised against their will.
It was not the only time that feminist organisations had united with various political actors to modify the law. In 2015, there were similar attempts, with 1,500 cases registered of what were termed “other forms of sexual violence”. Unfortunately, the modification of the PIR was scuppered, despite the fact that the international media (including the BBC) had announced that the Peruvian state would provide reparations along such lines. The justice minister at the time, Eduardo Vega Luna, who had been the ombudsman between 2011 and 2016, made clear to congresswoman Rocío Silva Santisteban, as well as to civil society and human rights organisations, that the debt to the victims of sterilisation was not something contemplated under the PIR. He added that, because of cutbacks in spending it would be impossible to extend reparations (from a personal interview with Rocío Silva).
International pressure has failed to modify this law which remains in force, impeding any reparations for forced sterilisation. Today we live in a state of violence in which both new and old political actors seek to reweave the narratives that deny recognition of the assaults committed on the bodies on Peruvian women. I personally would like to think that my 12-year-old daughter, walking down the street, is not a victim to physical or verbal assault. I would like to think that the pressure exerted by actors across the years would lead to significant changes in public policy or reproductive rights for the benefit of future generations. On this International Women’s Day I would like to think that we are not alone.
Recent Comments