On 7 December, the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) voted unanimously to suspend Patricia Benavides as the chief public prosecutor (Fiscal de la Nación) for a period of six months following investigations into how she and her team sought to pressure Congress to influence key appointments. She was to be replaced on an interim basis by Pablo Sánchez, but he indicated that he was unwilling to yet again act in this role having done so several times previously. Juan Carlos Villena is therefore due to be sworn in on 11 December.
As we reported last week, Benavides was identified as being at the heart of attempts to persuade key members of Congress to push ahead with blacklisting the former chief public prosecutor, Zoraida Avalos, appointing Josué Gutiérrez as ombudsman, and removing the current members of the JNJ from office.
Transcript recordings of WhatsApp conversations showed how Benavides’ assistant, Jaime Villanueva, had used an intermediary in Congress to put illegal pressure on parliamentarians from various parties to pursue her agenda, using the threat of investigations into their affairs as a weapon. Earlier this week, Villanueva was released from jail in a plea bargain deal whereby he spills the beans about what went on.
Benavides was summoned to appear before the JNJ on 5 December. Although she appeared before the Junta, she refused to undergo questioning. She and her lawyer, the former APRA prime minister Jorge del Castillo, claimed that the JNJ was violating due process.
Previously, Congress had failed to muster the majority vote required (64 in favour) for an attempt to initiate an investigation by the Justice Commission into the members of the JNJ over alleged conflicts of interest. 56 members voted in favour (including Fuerza Popular), 38 against and 15 abstained.
The prosecutor, Marita Barreto, who had led the investigation within the Ministerio Público into Benavides’ activities – and who was sacked by Benavides for her efforts – is to be reinstated.
Following her removal, on 7 December, Benavides attended a gathering at the Colegio de Abogados in Lima to celebrate the anniversary of Castillo’s ouster at which the head of the Combined Command of the Armed Forces, General Manuel Gómez de la Torres, was present. When asked about her suspension she attributed this to a “political plot” perpetrated by “dark forces.”
Sánchez was the most senior member of the board of chief prosecutors (JFS) and was first in line to replace Benavides. He had serviced previously as chief public prosecutor from 2015 to 2018 when he was replaced by Pedro Chavarry. He also served three times in an interim capacity when Juan Carlos Ramos was suspended in 2014, when Chávarry was removed in 2019, and following the ending of Avalos’s mandate in 2022.
In 2020, he was appointed coordinator of the special investigative team looking into the affair of the Cuellos Blancos del Puerto. Leaked phone recordings at the time suggested connections between corrupt judges and leading members of Fuerza Popular, one of the tapes referring to payments to a “Sra K”. The scandal involved members of the Consejo Nacional de la Magistratura (CNM), an entity subsequently abolished and replaced by the JNJ.
Chávarry, who had close contacts with Fuerza Popular and APRA, used his position to try to sack Rafael Vela and José Domingo Pérez, the two key investigators on the Lava Jato (Carwash) scandal. Among those implicated in this was Keiko Fujimori, the alleged recipient of massive illegal campaign funding in the 2011 and 2016 elections. Chávarry was dismissed as a judge by the JNJ in February 2021 for his presumed links with the Cuellos Blancos del Puerto group.
Following Sánchez’s reluctance to once again act as an interim replacement for Benavides, the post will be taken by Villena. Both Villena and Sánchez, who together made up the JFS had, on 27 November, called for Benavides’ resignation. Villena is expected to oversee a reorganisation of the way the public prosecution system operates.
Recent Comments