A section of the far-right majority in Congress is pushing ahead with its strategy to control judicial appointments through the National Board of Justice (Junta Nacional de Justicia, JNJ). It wants appointments to be placed in the hands of the Constitutional Tribunal (TC), an entity which it now effectively controls.

Jurists have expressed their concern that these moves represent a grave threat to democracy in Peru. According to Ivan Lanegra, the secretary general of Transparencia, it is up to civil society to protect the country’s democratic institutions. “The citizenry needs to react, to organise itself in defence of these attempts to weaken democratic institutions”, he said. Walter Albán, a former ombudsman, has said that it would be correct to describe the “subjugation” (“avasallamiento”) of democratic institutions as a “coup against institutionality”.

Ana Neyra, a lawyer and former minister of justice, is quoted as saying that “the Congress has identified important spaces within the state and has begun to capture them because they have the votes and have begun to capitalise on these in pursuit of this objective”.

The day after the appointment of Josué Gutiérrez as the new ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo), widely seen as a stitch-up between Perú Libre and the Fujimorista Fuerza Popular, the spokesperson for Avanza Pais, another far-right party, submitted a bill seeking to alter the legislation concerning the activities of the JNJ. It would give the president of the TC the leadership role of the special commission overseeing the selection of judges. Currently, this is a function exercised by the Defensor.

Avanza País has made no secret of its distrust of Gutiérrez, the candidate of PL for the position of Defensor, previously the lawyer of Vladimir Cerrón. In a ruling, the TC allowed the selection of the Defensor to go ahead without heeding judicial rulings that demanded greater public transparency in the hearings to this end. It appears to be the case that the scepticism of Avanza País is shared by another far-right party, Renovación Popular. It remains to be seen whether this position will also be shared by Fuerza Popular, the party that ensured Gutiérrez’s narrow victory.

At the same time, these parties remain wedded to the idea that the electoral authorities be brought under tighter congressional control. The constitutional commission in Congress is to consider moves that would denounce the heads of the three institutions, the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE), the Oficina Nacional de Procesos Electorales (ONPE), and the civil registry (RENIEC). Such accusations stem from those lodged by the losing parties in the 2021 elections who saw Castillo’s victory as fraudulent.

As Fernando Tuesta notes in an interview, these parties blame the electoral authorities for supposed fraud in 2021 while accepting the role they played in overseeing last year’s municipal and regional elections. As a result of these, Renovación Popular’s candidate for mayor of Lima, Rafael López Aliaga, was elected. Tuesta was previously the head of ONPE.