Amid accusations of irregularity, lack of transparency, and nefarious political interference, members of Congress this week finally chose a new ombudsman for Peru’s citizens. He is Josué Gutiérrez, elected by a whisker, winning just one vote more than the 87 needed to secure the post. His rival, the right-winger Jorge Rioja got 58.
Gutiérrez is a leftist, an advisor to Peru Libre and ex-lawyer of party founder Vladimir Cerrón, who received a four-year sentence for corruption in February 2023. Between 2011 and 2016, Gutiérrez served as a Nationalist Party member of Congress under Ollanta Humala.
The role of ombudsman or Defensor del Pueblo is key to defending the democratic rights of Peruvian citizens in a number of ways. Over the years, it has been one of the institutions that has done most to protect human and civil rights in Peru. It is meant to be independent and free from political interference. But since the process began to find a replacement for the incumbent, Eliana Revollar, political manoeuvring in Congress has been febrile.
As required for the post, Gutiérrez is a lawyer aged over 35 – but he has no human-rights experience. Neither did his main rival, Jorge Rioja, who furthermore is openly opposed to the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR). Both men, according to the online news outlet Servindi, are “candidates of questionable antecedents who got to the final round more for their political inclinations than for their merits”.
Gutiérrez’s win was made possible by a seemingly odd alliance of Keiko Fujimori’s far-right Fuerza Popular party voting with the far-left Peru Libre party, prompting former Defensor Walter Alban to tell La Republica that the new ombudsman will be the “el Defensor del Fujicerronismo”.
After weeks of delays and interruptions, the vote went ahead on 17 May without even a prior debate in Congress. Afterwards, Congress member Edward Málaga called foul and urged a rethink, but this did not get enough support.
Also seemingly dismissed was the IACHR’s urging of Congress to “adopt measures to strengthen the Defensoría institutionally in view of the important tasks that it carries out” and “to implement measures to ensure that the process of selecting a leader (…) is done in a manner that is participative, transparent, pluralist and based on the merits and professional qualifications of aspirants.”
Congress’ expansion of political influence is likely to go beyond the ombudsman’s office and into the justice system. The Defensor presides over the committee that will choose the next members of the National Board of Justice, the body that selects Peru’s judges, prosecutors and so on.
All of this points to a trend of power shifting further and further away from the people and towards a Congress that has been enjoying quite staggering rates of public disapproval since the year began.
Recent Comments