Energy and Mines Minister Guillermo Shinno this week set out an ambitious agenda for mining for the coming five years. Speaking at the GESS Social Management and Sustainability Forum in Lima, he said the government would seek to advance some US$40 billion of Peru’s US$64 billion mining investment portfolio.
Peru has no shortage of mining projects. Shinno says he intends to engage directly with companies to identify what is holding individual projects back. But perhaps the more interesting part of his intervention concerned what needs to happen in the territories involved.
Shinno argued that “true wealth is measured by the welfare, social peace and human development of the populations living in the territories where these resources are located”. He proposed moving away from the state’s traditionally reactive response to mining conflicts towards what he called “preventive territorial governance”: anticipating problems rather than intervening once conflicts have erupted, and planning territorial development with companies, local governments and communities.
This is a promising starting point, but easier said than done. For much of the last two decades, the Peruvian state’s response to mining conflict has been largely reactive. As a dispute escalates, typically government officials arrive, a dialogue table is established and agreements are reached, often involving commitments that public agencies subsequently struggle to fulfil. Getting the state involved before tensions become conflicts would be a step in the right direction.
But Shinno’s reference to welfare and human development suggests a more ambitious and worthwhile objective: not simply to prevent conflict so that mining projects can move forward, but to use mining investment to accelerate development in the territories where mining takes place.
His proposed changes to the mining canon bring the issue into focus. Shinno has argued that part of the canon should reach more directly communities close to mining operations, allowing them to see tangible improvements in infrastructure and basic services. The diagnosis addresses a real problem: substantial mining revenues have been transferred to subnational governments while populations living close to major operations may still lack adequate water, sanitation, health services and infrastructure.
But changing where the money goes does not by itself enhance the capacity of the state that receives and spends it. And there is also a question of scale. Some investments are necessarily local. Others, such as water systems, hospitals and transport infrastructure, require planning and coordination across districts and provinces. Territorial governance therefore needs to reconcile proximity, which matters for equity and legitimacy, with the scale required to provide effective public goods.
This is where Shinno’s proposals encounter the more fundamental challenge of state capacity. Here too, the minister’s first signals are encouraging. In an interview with El Comercio this week, he described a ministry burdened by bureaucratic bottlenecks, shortages of specialised technical staff and large administrative backlogs. He has clearly identified some of the important constraints he will face.
More broadly, he has acknowledged that getting mining projects moving cannot be separated from what happens in the territories where mining takes place, and that the benefits need to become more tangible for the populations that live there.
But the challenge implicit in his proposals goes considerably further. Territorial governance will require strengthening state capacity well beyond the Ministry of Energy and Mines itself, involving other parts of the national government as well as regional and local authorities.
This is the harder task. Peru’s problem has rarely been a shortage of mineral resources, mining revenues or development plans. It has been the capacity of the state to connect them and turn mineral wealth into functioning services, infrastructure and institutions.
Getting US$40 billion of mining investment moving would be an achievement. Building the state capacity to turn it into lasting development would be a much greater one. Whether this government will make meaningful progress in that direction remains to be seen.
Recent Comments