Lord John Alderdice, president of the Peru Support Group, and PSG’s coordinator, Ana Reyes-Hurt, visited Peru from 14-19 May. The visit coincided with the 20th anniversary of the publication of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) Report in 2003. It represented an opportunity to reflect on the progress, or lack of it, in implementing the TRC’s recommendations and to analyse the current human rights, political and institutional crises.

Lord Alderdice was previously the leader of the non-confessional Alliance Party in Northern Ireland. As such, he was one of the key negotiators of the Good Friday Agreement which brought conflict in Northern Ireland to an end. He was the first speaker of the new Northern Ireland Assembly.

He is a specialist in conflict resolution and has visited many countries that have, like Peru, undergone such processes of reconciliation. He has visited Peru several times, especially when working on the psychosocial aspects of political violence in the 1990s.

In 2004, he and former British minister and Labour MP John Battle published a report following up on the TRC report.

This time around, the delegates met with civil society organisations, international institutions, people from the business sector, and government authorities. It was clear that much had changed, and there have been positive developments since the TRC’s initial recommendations. These have included providing monetary reparations to victims and their families and the creation of the Victim’s Registry, as well as the adoption of the Law for the Search for the Disappeared. But other crucial areas have seen much less progress, including much-needed reforms to the security sector and in addressing the structural/underlying causes of violence, such as poverty, isolation, and discrimination.

During the visit, it became clear that spaces created to preserve the memory of the armed conflict and the lessons to be learned – most notably, the Lugar de la Memoria (LUM) (Place of Memory) – are increasingly under threat. Although many people find the right to memory uncomfortable and reject the notion that memory, the places that have been created to preserve it are vital for avoiding repetition.

The LUM was inaugurated in 2016. It is a space for reflection on the history of violence that Peru suffered from 1980-2000, providing concrete experiences and the accounts of both individuals and communities. For the PSG and its president, it was important to visit the LUM and highlight its role; the delegation thus took the opportunity to hold a public event there on 18 May, organised jointly by the LUM and the PSG. Marisol Pérez Tello, former Minister of Justice, and Manuel Burga, director of the LUM, as well as Lord Alderdice, spoke to an audience of around 30 people, including members of the press.

The event was held in the Sala Mama Angélica. Here you can appreciate the display on the ceiling of the Chalina de la Esparanza, a 1km long shawl made by more than 15,000 people, each weaving a square, to represent unity and the importance of thinking about each other. Burga began by welcoming Lord Alderdice and stressing the importance of the LUM’s work in understanding violence and its consequences for mental health. As readers will recall, the LUM was temporarily closed down by the right-wing mayor of Miraflores but has subsequently re-opened. Pérez Tello talked about the importance of maintaining a space for memory so as to stop current and future generations from changing the history. She also spoke about some specific advances made on the TRC recommendations, namely:

  • Understanding of the phenomenon of internal displacement in Peru from a humanitarian perspective.
  • Adoption of the law for the search of the disappeared, as well as one regulating the gene bank.
  • The Integral Plan for Reparations, as well as state recognition of violations committed.
  • Recognition of memory, with other sites aside from the LUM being developed, including one in Ayacucho. More funding is needed to complete these.

Lord Alderdice praised the achievement of having a museum of this kind. But he recognised that it may make some people uneasy. He pointed at the changes he had perceived over the last 20 years. More had been achieved earlier on, less in recent times, he said. Action on some areas like security reforms are still pending.

While he acknowledged that there are predisposing factors that produce violence which can be very destructive, to get rid of the problem at its root and stop it re-emerging you need to address these underlying issues. It seems clear, he said, that these have not been resolved in Peru, and the events of the past few months constitute evidence that supports this. The protests that broke out in December and January had been met with excessive use of force, resulting in many deaths.

As Lord Alderdice put it, “the impact of one bullet fired can have an impact that goes on for decades”, reflecting on a similar comment that had been said to him with respect to the troubles in Northern Ireland.

He spoke of three main issues surrounding memory:

  1. Memory is not just about facts, it’s about feelings – even if you don’t remember what was said, you remember how it made you feel. This is as true for individuals as for communities.
  2. Specific memories can often substitute for complex realities. People choose an event as significant, either a “chosen victory or a chosen trauma”. While it is important to retain these memories, sometimes they understate the complexity of situations.
  3. There is a community equivalent to PTSD, traumatic events that are not just memories but continue to be relived. As he pointed out, “it’s almost as though the capacity to put these things in the past and put them into memory is damaged”.

This, he said, is why spaces like the LUM are so important. The LUM tries to tell people that much has happened and that the events that shaped the story are complex, with many components. They can also help people situate things in time.

For him, it is extremely important to have places like this, not only because they keep the memory alive to avoid repetition, but they also help situate things in history, which allows us to learn and avoid repetition.

This is, he said, why it is crucial to maintain the museum and all that it represents, both practically and symbolically.

He also noted how important it is to ensure that all the numerous records of interviews made by the Commission 20 years ago, and held by the Defensoría del Pueblo, be digitised to preserve them against fire or other forces of loss.