Community members have continued to occupy the MMG Las Bambas copper mine in Apurímac. As we reported last week, the community of Fuerabamba and other local communities including Huancuire had camped in the mine’s property, in an attempt to reclaim land they had previously sold whilst claiming that the sale agreements had not been properly fulfilled by MMG.
It was estimated that around 200 community members from Fuerabambas were camping on the site on 27 April with numbers growing, and around 500 from Huancuire in another part of the mine.
The police forcibly removed some protestors on 27 April resulting in three being seriously injured, and the arrests of ten protestors and a journalist from the La República newspaper. The journalist claimed that he was unable to contact anyone for six hours, that his photographs were deleted, and his equipment taken. Not all the protesters were removed.
On the same day, the government declared a state of emergency in the area around Las Bambas for 30 days, temporarily suspending the right to assembly and protest. The government is reported to have claimed that the decision to take police action was made locally before the state of emergency.
The following day, community members again tried to enter and retake the land. Community members were reported to have surrounded the mine on four sides, in an attempt to enter from different points. Whilst the government then said it had not participated in the evictions, the police expelled more community members from the mine. At the time of writing, Fuerabamba community members had again been removed by the police, but those from Huancuire remained, possibly reflecting their different locations within the mine.
During the conflict police have used teargas whilst protesters have hurled rocks and damaged mine equipment. The second day resulted in more people injured; two community members and 15 police and workers of the mine, but local reports suggest many more suffered minor injuries.
Local business in Challhuahuacho closed down on 28 April as protestors marched through the streets, rallying against the mine and protesting against police violence. A police van was set alight. Local police forces were subsequently reinforced by officers from outside the area, and residents of the town were told not to leave their homes after 7.30pm.
Local community leaders say that they feel abandoned by the government and that the mine has not met its commitments. The president of the community of Fuerabamba said on 27 April “Las Bambas won’t continue. There will be no more talking. We have hoped and waited in good faith, we have sent letters to President Castillo and the prime minister and we get nothing. They have waited to massacre us. They have declared war on us.” Later he stated that “The communal agreement is that there is no dialogue. We are hurt by the betrayal of the government. Now I can’t do anything, I can’t control the community, the community is now decided to reclaim its land.”
The conflict highlights the complexity of managing rights to benefits from mining, and the high stakes for all actors in the successful management of competing interests, particularly for those communities directly affected by mining. In this case, MMG relocated the community of Fuerabamba and had to identify a site with sufficient land to replace that which Fuerabamba had given up. This was no easy task. The current dissatisfaction of Fuerabamba may also have been reignited by the apparent reclaiming of New Fuerabamaba’s land by the community that previously owned it, as well as other contractual concerns with which they claim MMG did not comply. The community of Huancuire also claims that it sold land to Las Bambas and that the company has not upheld its commitments under the agreement whereby the benefits of the mine would be enjoyed by the community.
The current resort to force to resolve mining conflicts follows a long line of attempts that have failed to deal successfully with the conflicting interests over mining, including attaining and honouring agreements with local communities. This latest conflict, over such an important mine to the Peruvian economy, is another wake-up call for the need to find a better way for governments to engage with such complex issues.
Initially, the Castillo government had highlighted the need to ensure that communities receive their fair share of the benefits from mining. This latest move has been widely criticised for resorting to more time-honoured methods of confronting protest.
Recent Comments