Nearly eight years after a group of journalists brought the case against the acquisition by the El Comercio group of media companies Epense and ABS, Judge Juan Macedo Cuenca has finally ruled that this contravened constitutional guarantees about press freedom.
In 2013, Luz Helguero, Fernando Valencia, Augusto Alvarez Rodrich, Mirko Lauer, Rosa María Palacios, Gustavo Mohme, Enrique Zileri and Marion Saavedra-Pinón brought the case against El Comercio, arguing that its purchase of media companies Epensa and ABS violated the 1993 constitution and various international treaties regarding press freedom and plurality.
The acquisitions by El Comercio greatly reinforced El Comercio’s dominant position in the Peruvian media market. According to the judge, international treaties “oblige states not to allow dominant positions or concentrated markets in communications media, and individuals oblige them not to take part in such concentration [of ownership]”.
The judgement, which will be appealed by El Comercio, was based on Article 2 and Article 61 of the 1993 constitution which refer to freedom of information and media exclusivity. Article 61 states that “companies, goods and services relating to freedom of expression and communication cannot be the object of exclusivity, monopoly or the cornering of the market (acaparamiento), whether directly or indirectly, on the part of the state or individuals”.
Although media ownership is highly concentrated in many Latin American countries, Peru is one of the most egregious examples. According to the Media Ownership Monitor, on the basis of figures from 2016, the El Comercio group accounts for an estimated 80% of newspaper circulation. It also has a major share of the television and online news markets.
It is, perhaps, ironical, that this judgement comes at a time when El Comercio has been slated for its one-sided coverage of the elections. It has played an important role in helping to boost the vote for Keiko Fujimori.
Recent Comments