It has long been established that an outgoing president in Peru receives a pension plus a number of other benefits. Currently that pension is 15,600 soles a month, roughly equivalent to US$3,800. But should a president who serves only a short period receive the same? The issue has come to the surface in dramatic fashion due to the demand by Manuel Merino – who acted as president for five days – to receive this benefit.

The constitution and the law provide little guidance on such a thorny issue. In Merino’s case, the extremely short period for which he was president last November – following the impeachment of Martín Vizcarra – would render a life pension unreasonable. Merino resigned following angry street demonstrations over the way he assumed office.

But there are also others lining up for a life pension. Francisco Sagasti wants one, having served as president for nine months. Like Merino, he took over without ever having been elected president. He says he is prepared to forego the perks of having a car provided and subsidised fuel for it. Vizcarra also wants the pension. In his case, he served for longer (over two and a half years) and was at least elected (as vice-president) in 2016.

Where is the line to be drawn?