Notwithstanding criticisms by noted constitutionalists, the congressional committee in charge of selecting members of the Constitutional Tribunal finished their interviews of candidates on 23 June. The NGO Transparencia, in particular, has slated the procedures adopted and has warned of the possible consequences of a politically biased court being elected.
The Constitutional Tribunal plays a fundamental role in guaranteeing democratic norms in Peru. It is the sole institution capable of resolving constitutional disputes. Its profile in this respect has been greatly increased since 2016 when Keiko Fujimori opted to use her party’s majority in Congress to lambast the executive, both ministers and the presidency itself.
In a statement Transparency declared that the congressional committee had failed to respect procedures that were transparent, impartial and meritocratic in electing magistrates “of a recognised professional trajectory, appropriate moral standing and proven democratic trajectory in respecting and defending the constitutional order”.
In several cases the 17 candidates were quizzed about their religious values and their opinions on polemical political issues rather than on their judicial expertise.
Leading constitutionalists have argued that it is inappropriate for outgoing members of Congress to be leading the appointment processes that have long been delayed and that it would be better for the new Congress, elected in April, to assume this role.
Recent Comments