The war within Peru’s judicial system entered a new phase this week when, on 25 April, the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) ruled that the dismissal of Inés Tello and Aldo Vásquez as members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) fell fully within the competences of the legislature. An earlier judicial ruling had blocked the sacking of the two JNJ members. The cautionary measure that restored Tello and Vásquez is thus suspended pending an appeal lodged with the Supreme Court.

The lawyer acting for Inés Tello described the judgement of the TC as “unprecedented” and an “absurdity” (despropósito) which the judicial branch should not take “lying down” (“se doblegue”). The College of Lawyers in Lima is quoted as saying that “the recent decision of the TC weakens the democratic regime in the country”.

The ruling is likely further to heighten controversy over the decisions of the TC. As readers of the newsletter will recall, in May 2022 Congress voted in members of the TC broadly sympathetic to the positions of the far-right majority in the legislature. The previous members of the TC had been far less susceptible to pressures from Congress.

The procedures by which six new members of the seven-member TC were selected were widely criticised for the lack of transparency and debate. They involved what was called at the time a ‘stitch-up’ (repartija) between members of Peru Libre and the main far-right parties in Congress led by Fuerza Popular.

The JNJ, which is responsible for the selection of judges and public prosecutors as well as the heads of Peru’s three electoral bodies, is at the heart of the ongoing struggle over control of Peru’s judicial system. Key to this is the future of the suspended chief public prosecutor, Patricia Benavides. She stands accused of trading favours by which investigations into corruption by members of Congress were sidelined in return for support for Benavides’ attempts to purge the public prosecution service of officials reluctant to toe her line.

Benavides also stands accused of using her influence to derail investigation into the ‘Cuellos Blancos del Puerto’ corruption scandal involving senior members of the judiciary in which her sister, Emma, a judge, was involved. Other cases of improper behaviour have also emerged, including the use of contracts to favour specific firms in return for bribes.

However, the JNJ will continue in its efforts to decide whether Benavides should be permanently removed from her role as chief public prosecutor. In December 2023 she was suspended for six months. The TC has agreed that the JNJ is within its rights to determine her future. Benavides appears to have connived with the present head of the TC, Francisco Morales, to prevent the JNJ investigating her.

Through her lawyer, Jorge del Castillo, the prominent Aprista politician, Benavides has denied the charges lodged against her.

Benavides’ replacement as chief public prosecutor, Juan Carlos Villena, has played a major role in seeking to clean up the Ministerio Público and deal with the corruption within its ranks. This week Villena removed three prosecutors appointed by Benavides following an operation known as Valkiria II to root out corrupt elements in the service.

On 27 April, Villena launched an inquiry into President Dina Boluarte for bribery over her receipt of Rolex watches and jewellery by Ayacucho governor Wilfredo Oscorima.