On 10 January, Alejandro Soto Reyes, the president of Congress, promulgated a law that opens the door to the further rapid deforestation of the Peruvian Amazon. He did so without consideration of two appeals that had been awaiting a vote.
Congress had approved amendments to the Forestry and Wildlife Law that would effectively dismantle the country’s legal constraints on deforestation after only a 15-minute debate late on the second-to-last day of the 2023 legislative session. They threaten the survival of the Amazon rainforest, legitimise illegal logging and land invasions, endanger indigenous environmental rights defenders, and put at risk numerous international commitments made by the Peruvian state.
These amendments to the forestry law were first introduced in Congress in July 2022. During the course of 2023 at least eleven legislative proposals threatened the conservation of the Amazon and promised to pave the way for crimes against the environment.
The legislation had been previously approved by Congress but had been vetoed by the executive and returned to Congress for further consideration, where they needed a second vote (“insistencia”) by Congress to override the veto and become law. On 13 December, Alfonso Bustamante, president of CONFIEP (the peak private sector lobby organisation) sent a letter to Soto, urging that the Congress override the executive veto. Within 24 hours the amendments passed with 69 votes in favour, 35 against, and with five abstentions.
The proposed changes had been strenuously opposed by indigenous leaders and environmental activists, but to no avail. Ironically, the original legislation had been the first law to be approved by Congress honouring the free, prior, and informed consent of indigenous peoples. On 15 December, the last day of the last legislative session, opposition congresswomen Ruth Luque and Susel Paredes presented requests that the enforcement of the amendments be suspended pending reconsideration by Congress in the first legislative session of 2024.
The legal structure designed to control deforestation involves the zoning of land according to its suitability for forestry or agricultural and livestock activities. Zoning is a technical process carried out by the Forestry Service (Serfor), which makes recommendations to the Environment Ministry (Minam) for approval. Existing forest lands can only be converted to exploitation for agriculture and livestock rearing if the land has been deemed suitable for such activities and where Minam acts on the advice of Serfor.
In practice, however, enforcement had been weak and extensive areas of rainforest have been deforested irrespective of the regulations. It is estimated that 150,000 to 200,000 hectares of forest are lost each year in Peru.
The amendments to the old law will remove the requirement for zoning approval for agriculture and livestock on deforested lands and will enable private landholders to attain land titles without such approval. Further, zoning proposals and amendments presented by Serfor will now be approved by the Ministry of Agriculture, not Minam. This implies a change in priorities from the conservation of the forest to its exploitation for its resources.
If these changes stick and are enforced, they will legalise and formalise the conversion of forest into agriculture and livestock raising for thousands of mainly small landholders, migrants from the highlands, enabling them to establish farms on deforested land. It will also open the way for a smaller number of cacao and palm oil plantation companies that have occupied, deforested, and exploited the forest without obtaining the necessary permits. It will also encourage illegal logging, land trafficking and the occupation and deforestation of land for coca cultivation. The interest groups involved in these activities are all well represented in Congress and in the regional governments of Amazonia. The sponsor of the new Forestry Law, Elizabeth Medina, is well known for her contacts with coca-growing interests.
Although the new law does not directly affect indigenous peoples, it will have serious indirect consequences. It will increase the pressures on indigenous territories from land invaders engaged in both legal and illegal activities, especially in those communities that lack land titles or those that are seeking to expand their entitlements. It will therefore increase levels of conflict and violence, further threaten indigenous environmental and human rights defenders, and place at greater risk those indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation who already confront illegal loggers and miners.
The law will have important international implications too. It is estimated that about 60% of Peru’s annual greenhouse gas emissions are the result of deforestation, largely in the Amazon. Peru’s commitments under the Paris Agreement involve a steady and substantial reduction in the rate of deforestation. Peru has also signed trade agreements with the United States and the European Union which include commitments to reduce deforestation.
Those affected by the amendments have been swift in their response.
- On 16 December a pronouncement condemning the measures was signed and published by more than 200 civil society and indigenous organisations and 1,100 individuals. On 20 December letters signed by 70 organisations were sent to the European Commission and the EU embassy in Lima alerting them to the changes and the resulting violation of international agreements.
- The US-based environmental and human rights organisation Amazon Watch has condemned the amendments as likely to depenalise illegal logging, encourage criminal activities, undermine climate commitments, and place at risk millions of dollars in bilateral projects with Norway, the United States, the United Kingdom and the EU.
- The national Amazonian indigenous organization AIDESEP has highlighted in its pronouncement not only the threat of deforestation but also the weakening of climate change commitments, the violation of the right to free, prior and informed consent and the potential impacts on agricultural exports to the UE.
- The Peruvian Environmental Law Society (SPDA) claims that the amendments violate international environmental commitments, endanger forest governance, eliminate the need for technical studies to classify forest lands and legalise past deforestation.
- Arguing that the legislative changes are unconstitutional, the Legal Defence Institute (IDL) claims that “what this decision seeks is that forest lands should pass from a focus on the protection of natural resources to a focus on agricultural production through the elimination of land zoning and the prohibition of land use changes”. It continues “What it seeks in reality is to greenwash deforestation and, more concretely, legalise and formalise illegal activities. . . All the investigations by the police, prosecutors and judicial processes against loggers will be filed away, condoning the deforestation of thousands of hectares of Amazonian rainforest.”
Recent Comments