As we have previously reported, a Fuerza Popular (FP) congressman submitted a draft law in November to Congress which would transfer the responsibility for governing the seven indigenous reserves created to protect Amazonian indigenous groups in voluntary isolation. The proposal rang alarm bells among indigenous peoples and their supporters, both in the executive and within civil society. Such isolation stems from the fear, among other things, that interactions with the outside world could generate infections that threaten the existence of isolated indigenous peoples.
The proposal would transfer responsibility for the reserves to regional governments. These tend to be subject to strong pressures from local logging, mining and drug trafficking interests. Proponents of the legislation have argued that the very existence of such groups in isolation is in doubt. They want the reserves to be eliminated.
The draft law was submitted to the Congress’s Culture and Cultural Heritage Commission for consideration and approval in the hope that the Commission would make a positive recommendation to the Congressional plenary. But, according to established protocols, it should have been presented first to the Indigenous and First Nations’ Peoples Commission in Congress.
On 13 March, the Culture Commission decided by eight votes to three votes (with one abstention) to inhibit itself from ruling on the proposal, arguing that it should be sent for consideration to the Indigenous and First Nations’ Peoples Commission.
Both the Ministry for the Environment and the national Ombudsman’s office, the Defensoría del Pueblo, have opposed the draft law. The national indigenous organization AIDESEP has argued that twelve legal opinions from government agencies and indigenous organisations maintain that the proposed legislation is unconstitutional.
Nevertheless, as Congress now exercises more control over the Constitutional Tribunal and is in the process of appointing a new Ombudsman, the future of the proposed measure – and of the survival of isolated indigenous peoples – still hangs in the balance.
Recent Comments