The conservative parties that form the majority in Congress are keen to push ahead with the election of an ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo) who will do their bidding. Not only is the Defensoría a key office of state in providing a semi-independent view on human rights issues, but since 2019 the Defensor plays an important role in chairing the special commission to select members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia.

The JNJ is the entity responsible for appointing, dismissing and overseeing the country’s judges and prosecutors. The commission will probably be chosen next year since the JNJ’s mandate expires in December 2024.

The election of a new Defensor is now pending in the Congress with different parties pushing for their preferred candidates. The job of Defensor has been carried out in recent years on an interim basis. Judicial authorities have made clear their concern that a new Defensor will be beholden to Congress and will seek to use the office to influence the selection of judges.

A recent decision by the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) seeks to enhance further congressional control over the office of the Defensoría. On 15 March, a majority on the Supreme Court issued the following statement. “The Judicial Power cannot agree with the reasons adduced by the ruling of the Constitutional Tribunal. Indeed, it expresses its concern about the judicial reasoning behind it and underlines the grave impacts it may have for the protection of fundamental rights of citizens and for the independence of the judiciary”.

The ruling of the TC also threatens to compromise the independence of other institutions, notably those making up the electoral system.