On 13 November workers from the Ministry of Culture (Mincul) announced the assassination of a Mastanahua family, one of only six indigenous groups in initial contact, near the Maschco-Piro Indigenous Reserve and the Alto Purus National Park. Mincul supposedly protects such people, along with the National Protected Areas Service (SERNANP) which comes under the Ministry of the Environment (Minam).

The Ucayali regional indigenous organization (ORAU) has expressed its concern that the assassinations were associated with illegal activities, namely illegal logging and drug trafficking. These they say are carried out in or near such supposedly protected areas. It has asked Mincul to investigate.

As a result of the violence they face, families from the nearby Santa Rey and Balta indigenous communities have sought refuge in the district capital of Puerto Esperanza. ORAU has asked Mincul to provide these families with accommodation, food and other supplies whilst they remain there. It has called on the prime minister’s office to strengthen security and to eradicate drug trafficking from both the park and the reserve.

The story behind this tragedy once again reveals the vulnerability of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and initial contact and the limitations of public policy in protecting their rights and territories.

Until 2003, the family in question lived in voluntary isolation in the forest. However, in that year a Christian religious organization called ‘Pioneers’ arrived with the mission to convert the indigenous by enticing them out of the forest with small gifts. Only the small Mastanahua group succumbed to these enticements, moving closer to communities already in regular contact.

For two decades, they played an intermediary role between other Pano-speaking groups (such as the Marinahua, Dishinahua, Chitonahua and others), who remained in isolation, and indigenous and non-indigenous outsiders.

For the Pano speakers still in isolation, the family in question provided access to tools, clothing and food from the in-contact communities and information about the best moment for organizing raids. At the same time, the family provided outsiders with information about the whereabouts and activities of the groups in isolation.

This delicate balancing act made them vulnerable. The increased presence of both drug traffickers smuggling cocaine across the nearby border with Brazil and of illegal loggers made it increasingly dangerous for the Arawak-speaking Maschco Piro (the other main indigenous people) to access their traditional territories. They ended up being displaced and provoked into aggression towards other groups. Rather than outsiders, it is thus assumed that the family was assassinated by the Maschco Piro who were under pressure from illegal actors.

On 9 December, the Inter-American Human Rights Commission (IAHRC) held hearings in response to complaints from indigenous organisations about the failure of the Peruvian state adequately to protect indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and initial contact. Specifically, the IAHRC expressed its concern over the delay in creating indigenous reserves and the granting of official logging concessions on or near such reserves. It referred specifically to the recent assassination of the Mastanahua family as an example of such peoples’ vulnerability and their lack of adequate protection.

Jorge Pérez, president of the indigenous organization ORPIO, pointed out that Law No. 28736, designed to protect peoples in isolation, states that the recognition of indigenous reserves should take no longer than two years. Nevertheless, most applications for the creation of such reserves have been under way for between 15 and 25 years without any decision being made.

As for logging concessions, Pérez argued that there are 97 authorised concessions, of which 82 overlap with the territories claimed as indigenous reserves and a further 13 border on such territories. At least 43 concessions were granted after 2015 when the Forestry and Wildlife Law was passed. This law states that no logging or wildlife concessions will be granted in territories under consideration for conversion to indigenous reserves. Finally, a draft law, currently stuck in Congress (No. 4044), proposes that there be no exceptions to the prohibition against concessions in indigenous reserves.

Despite the existence of legislation providing for the creation of reserves to protect the rights and livelihoods of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and initial contact and prohibiting logging and other concessions on such territories, the reality is different. Few reserves have been created, while proposals for the creation of new reserves have been under consideration for decades. Logging concessions have been granted on or near territories set aside for this purpose, and under-resourced state agencies provide little or no proper protection to indigenous people living in those areas where reserves have been created.