This week has seen further news of indigenous in voluntary isolation being displaced by loggers in the Madre de Dios region. We have reported regularly over the years about the Mashco Piro indigenous in voluntary isolation in the Madre de Dios region making appearances in the Piedras river opposite the Yine Monte Salvado community demanding food. This usually occurs during the dry season in the Amazon when the level of the rivers is low, and food is scarce. We reported the latest appearance three weeks ago.

This week the London-based indigenous rights organisation Cultural Survival circulated photos in the media showing 24 indigenous males on 26 June and 52 on 27 June demanding food from the startled inhabitants of the Monte Salvado community. This has led to a virtual storm of media stories describing the Mashco Piro as the largest indigenous group in voluntary isolation in the Amazon and ascribing their appearance to their displacement by logging activities on their traditional territory.

The Canales Tahuamanu company was awarded a concession partially overlapping the indigenous territory before the Covid pandemic and has increased the level of its activities since the pandemic ended, including some 200 kilometers of roads. The increased proximity of the logging company and the indigenous in isolation has raised concerns about the possibility of violent conflicts and the spread of diseases for which the indigenous have no resistance.

Indeed, the regional indigenous federation FENAMAD has been demanding the cancelation of the logging concession since the beginning of the pandemic and has joined Survival International in also demanding that the Forest Stewardship Council cease to certify Canales Tahuamanu as socially and environmentally responsible.

The concern about possible violence is also due to the killing of a member of the Monte Salvado community after a random encounter with Mashco Piro and the killing of one off-duty logger and the wounding of another while fishing.

Elsewhere, and as we reported last week, the assassination of the young Kakataibo indigenous leader, Mariano Isacama, attributed to coca growers and their allies and/or illegal loggers, is the sixth Kakataibo leader assassinated since 2020 and the latest in a list of some 35 indigenous indigenous environmental and human rights defenders assassinated in the last ten years.

The incident has led to a flurry of articles demanding greater protection for indigenous leaders. Ojo Publico has reported that nearly a quarter of the threats received by indigenous leaders come from those involved in illegal logging and drug trafficking. Those peoples receiving most threats are the Kichwa, Shipibo-konibo, Kakataibo, Asháninka, Wampis and Yanesha.

At the national level, 373 risk situations involving 656 persons have been registered, of which 24% have been linked to illegal logging, 17% to land trafficking, 17% to drug trafficking and 12% to illegal mining.

It has been reported that on 15 July twelve members of the Kichwa community of Puerto Franco in San Martín region were captured by some 30 illegal loggers when patrolling in the Alto Biavo district. AIDESEP, the national indigenous organisation, is demanding the immediate intervention of the Interior Ministry.

As we have repeatedly argued, such incidents reflect either the absence of the state or its reluctance to act in remote regions where armed actors are present. Despite protocols proffered by the Justice Ministry to offer protection, in practice these guarantees have been meaningless; the police and judicial authorities lack the means and willingness to act.

Consequently, many leaders and their families have been forced to flee their communities, leaving the remaining community members fearful and leaderless. The lack of state protection extends to the widows and children of assassinated leaders who often are not guaranteed protection or do not receive the compensation and benefits to which they are entitled.

In this situation of conflict between the armed and unarmed, and an ineffective state, it is not surprising to hear national indigenous leaders declare that they are going to take the law into their own hands and apply ‘indigenous justice’.

An instance of this was the expulsion on 19 July of Mennonites by an indigenous militia formed by members of the Shipibo Conibo community of Caimito. The Mennonites had obtained possession of indigenous territory at Masisea through land trafficking and then had deforested the land to establish large-scale farms.

In December 2023, the Mennonites received a judicial order to stop deforesting. They ignored the order, arguing that they had certificates of possession and that the lands did not belong to the Caimito community. It remains to be seen whether such forcible action will prevail.