An attack on loggers by members of the Mashco Piro, an indigenous group in voluntary isolation, in territory designated for inclusion in an expanded indigenous reserve, highlights the risks arising from confusion over extractive concessions in such areas. It again shows the need for the state to resolve current contradictions within its policies to protect human rights.

On August 21, two off-duty loggers were attacked by Mashco Piro members in voluntary isolation. One was later found dead and the other ended up in the Santa Rosa regional hospital recovering from two arrow wounds. The workers were fishing on the Tahuamanu river in an area which forms part of the traditional territory of the Mashco Piro. This is to be included in a planned expansion of the Madre de Dios indigenous reserve, but it also forms part of a logging concession awarded to the Maderera Canales Tahuamanu timber company, known as Catahua.

Catahua is certified by the Forest Stewardship Council. It operates two concessions in an area where isolated indigenous have been sighted and it recently won a legal dispute with the Nueva Oceanía Boca Supiwi, an indigenous community not in voluntary isolation. This led to the community losing its legal recognition. The area is under consideration for inclusion in a proposed extension of the Madre de Dios Territorial Reserve, a move supported by the regional indigenous federation FENAMAD.

In October 2020, the company sued FENAMAD for “violating its right to honour and a good reputation and image” in denouncing the company for operating in the Mashco Piro territory during the Covid-19 health emergency. The company won the case in the first and second instances with a final verdict handed down in December 2021.

According to EarthRights International, this judicial decision limits FENAMAD’s ability to defend the rights of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. In August 2020, the company accused FENAMAD of corrupting and manipulating regional authorities.

In response, FENAMAD has emphasised the serious risks involved in allowing extractive activities and indeed the presence of outsiders in the territories of indigenous people in voluntary isolation. It is demanding that the state assume responsibility for having permitted and promoted activities leading to these regrettable events. For its part, the Ministry of Culture claims that it maintains five control posts in Madre de Dios and 17 protection agents who carry out patrolling and monitoring activities to identify possible threats to peoples in voluntary isolation.

FENAMAD’s president, Julio Cusirichi, argues that “there cannot be a territorial reserve where there are economic activities because this goes against the no-contact principle and the intangibility of territorial reserves, especially when highly vulnerable humans are involved”. He also claims that the Inter-American Human Rights Commission has issued a protection measure relating to this, since in 2016 the extension of the Madre de Dios Territorial Reserve was approved although it has yet to be officially promulgated via a supreme decree.

In 2019 the National Natural Protected Areas Service (SERNANP) withdrew its personnel from their control post in the area because of the frequent incursions of isolated indigenous peoples.

Meanwhile, the press in Lima reports that the creation of the recently approved Napo Tigre Indigenous Reserve in Loreto region is in danger because of a legal action launched by the Anglo-French oil company, Perenco. Perenco claims that the reserve will interfere with its rights to explore and exploit petroleum in Blocks 67 and 39, situated in the same area.