An important development this last week has been the judicial decision declaring the Maranon River, in the northern Amazon jungle, the subject of rights in nature. Kukama indigenous women are celebrating the court decision, made in Nauta on 18 March. They have been fighting for years to protect the river from oil spills and other forms of pollution. They also have been attempting to stop plans to dredge the river and build dams that would impact its flow and reduce the supply of fish on which communities depend for sustenance.
In a press release issued the following day, Mariluz Canaquiri Murayari, president of the Kukama Women, admitted that “this probably isn’t the end” but that “this encourages us to keep fighting in defence of our territories and our rivers”.
It is more than likely that the Peruvian state will appeal the Nauta court’s decision. In her ruling, the judge drew a distinction between “sujeto de derecho” (the term the lawsuit requested for the river and which translates as “legal personhood”) and “titular de derecho”, which is what she granted.
According to the judge, Peru’s constitution prohibits recognising a non-human as a human, and so her way of getting around it was to use the term “titular de derechos”. The judge granted the river the same rights the Kukama women were requesting. It might seem a mute argument about semantics, but it shows how the legal system fails to respect indigenous worldviews which grant personhood to non-humans in nature.
The ruling represents a ‘first’ in Peruvian jurisprudence. Elsewhere in Latin America, the rights of nature have been acknowledged.
Recent Comments