Faced with the imminence of next year’s general election, the issue of reform to the law governing political parties has gained salience in the Congress, but the draft produced by the congressional constitution commission has been criticised by the electoral authorities as well as specialist NGOs. The critics include Francisco Távara, none other than the president of the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE) the organisation responsible for validating election results.

It has long been clear that the 2003 Law on Political Parties failed in its attempts to build a solid party system rooted in society and organised along transparent and democratic lines. Attempts to reform this legislation have been repeatedly shelved with opposition to change coming, in the main, from the congressmen and party leaders elected under the existing system.

The current reform proposals, it was widely hoped, would remedy some of the deficiencies in the present system in advance of the 2015-16 election campaign. This does not now seem to be the case. According to Percy Medina, head of the Lima office of IDEA (a Swedish-based international NGO dedicated to promoting democracy) “we run the risk of doing reforms that comply with the agenda, but not in the correct direction. Or, worse than this, instead of advancing, we retreat from what we are looking for”. http://larepublica.pe/impresa/politica/704092-alertan-que-dictamen-de-ley-de-partidos-significa-un-retroceso

For the JNE, as well as the ONPE (the organisation responsible for organising elections), the draft law lacks key proposals that would render parties more financially transparent. The bill before Congress does not, for instance, include proposals to bring party funding under tighter control. Nor does it include effective penalties when parties fail to provide proper information on party’s sources of income; in fact it weakens the few controls that currently exist.

Both organisations are also concerned to reform the way that internal elections of leaders and candidates are conducted. They are critical of the bill in failing to allow them to provide logistical help in organising such elections or oversight as to the way they are conducted. They also oppose the lifting of the percentage of ‘invited candidates’ (i.e. candidates who are not party members) from the present 20% limit to 25%.

In his appeal to Congress, Távara urged legislators to take on board his criticisms before proceeding to a final vote. http://larepublica.pe/politica/704149-cambios-en-ley-de-partidos-politicos-debe-generar-verdadero-impacto-en-la-democracia But with a vote imminent on the issue, it seemed unlikely that his comments (and those of other experts) would be heeded. http://elcomercio.pe/politica/congreso/fredy-otarola-tendencioso-decir-que-reforma-electoral-se-caera-noticia-1841929?ref=nota_politica&ft=mod_interesa&e=titulo