In votes cast by Congress on 7 March, members voted to bar two of the seven who make up the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) from public office. However, they failed to remove the other five. For months, parties of the extreme right, led by Fuerza Popular, have sought to get rid of the current members of the JNJ and replace them by people more compliant with their wishes. The JNJ is responsible for appointing judges and prosecutors as well as the electoral authorities.

As we have repeatedly pointed out, the JNJ is a crucial institution of the state protecting the autonomy of the judiciary. Many members of Congress have investigations open in the public prosecutor’s office and stand to benefit from greater control over judicial appointments. The parties of the right are also anxious to increase the degree of control they exercise over the election authorities prior to the 2026 elections.

Taken together with the constitutional amendments on re-election and the restoration of the Senate , steps taken over the past week represent significant advances in the strategy of state capture by politicians of the right.

The two JNJ members now barred from public office are Inés Tello and Aldo Vásquez. The justification for congressional moves against the JNJ was the fact that Tello, now over 75, should no longer belong to the JNJ and that the JNJ supported her by claiming that she was voted in before she was 75 for a five-year term of office. Although the rules on this point are confused, the reprisals by Congress are widely seen as grossly disproportionate and simply part of a campaign to replace the current members of the JNJ.

In the case of Tello, 67 members voted for her removal. Their number included José Luna Gálvez who, as a member of the Permanent Commission in Congress, should not have voted. Without his vote, there would have been no majority (there are 130 members of Congress, and 67 votes is the minimum required). Complaints on this score and demands for a second vote were summarily overruled by the president of Congress, Alejandro Soto.

In the case of Vásquez, the JNJ vice-president and a former justice minister, the vote against him was approved initially by only 65 votes, but a second vote was allowed in which he reached 67 votes. Two members, both under investigation, switched their vote.

Both Tello and Vásquez had opened proceedings against Patricia Benavides, the suspended chief public prosecutor accused of heading up a ‘criminal organisation’ from within the Ministerio Público by which corruption cases were suspended in return for congressional support.

The other JNJ members will remain in office since the votes against them failed to reach the necessary majorities.

The moves against the members of the JNJ have raised serious questions about the future independence of the judiciary in Peru, notably within the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. Some far-right members of Congress have advocated Peru’s leaving the San José Pact that underpins the system of Inter-American justice.