Initial opposition to legislation by Congress to amend the forestry law, overriding the objections of the executive, has been followed by a wave of criticism and objections from popular organisations, the Church, specialists, allied governments, and the United Nations. A lawsuit asserting that the amendments are illegal and unconstitutional and a bill to amend the amendments have also been presented.
The debate over the future of the Amazon and measures to control deforestation is thus far from over. It has regional, national and international dimensions.
On 18 January, the Awajún Autonomous Territorial Government (GTAA), representing 70,000 indigenous peoples from the Amazonas, Loreto, Cajamarca and San Martín regions, demanded that the law be repealed. This is because it relaxes the controls on illegal logging and other extractive activities in the forest, promotes the illegal appropriation of indigenous lands by land traffickers, and undermines the legal and institutional bases for environmental conservation.
A loose alliance of environmentalists, university students and Amazonian indigenous leaders marched on Congress on 25 January to demand that the new forestry law be repealed and to denounce the irregular way it was passed. They also demanded that the role of the Ministry for the Environment (Minam) in making decisions regarding environmental conservation be strengthened.
The march was supported by the forestry students’ organisation at the National Agrarian University, the Peruvian branch of Fridays for Future, the Peruvian Environmental Students Network, Articulated Environmental Activists, and the national Amazonian Indigenous federation AIDESEP.
Also on 25 January, the Peruvian Bishops’ Conference issued a statement claiming that the recent changes to the forestry legislation favoured the deforestation of the Amazon and placed it at serious risk. They demanded that the authorities reconsider the law’s approval.
The National Council of the Deans of all Peru’s professional organisations questioned the speed and form of the approval of the forestry law and expressed concern at its negative impacts on the Amazon, on environmental defenders and isolated peoples, and the way it violates the right to prior consultation.
At the international level, the United Nations Special Rapporteur for the Rights of Indigenous Peoples sent a grave warning to the Peruvian government that the new law would promote impunity for illegal activities in the Amazon and would increase levels of violence against indigenous rights defenders. It could also lead to the legalisation of land grabbing to the detriment of indigenous communities. According to the Special Rapporteur, “owing to the great pressure on unprotected indigenous territories, the creation [under the law] of areas of exclusion could generate impunity for illegal logging and other forms of deforestation, weakening the fight against deforestation and aggravating the current climate crisis”.
On 18 January, the ambassadors of Norway, the United Kingdom, Germany, and Canada issued a joint statement urging Congress to reconsider the law because it threatens to undermine protection of the rainforest and the livelihoods of indigenous communities and that it would encourage illegal activities in indigenous territories. It would therefore place defenders of indigenous lands and their natural resources at risk. This, they said, is particularly a concern given that there are still over 700 communities whose territories are still untitled.
In 2014, the Norwegian and German governments signed with Peru a Joint Declaration of Intention to conserve the Amazonian rainforest and control deforestation. Subsequently, they were joined by the UK and US governments in providing funding and technical advice. Such moves were designed to ensure the gradual decline in rates of deforestation deemed necessary to reduce the country’s greenhouse gas emissions and meet its climate change targets. The implementation of this programme has been very uneven, and the new forestry law further undermines international confidence in the country’s commitment to its climate change objectives. Prime Minister Alberto Otárola has promised to use “constitutional means” to renew the debate over the law.
On 23 January, the forestry specialist and consultant Rodrigo Arce published a detailed analysis of the legislation. He concluded that, in the name of landless small-scale farmers who legitimately deserve a sustainable response from the state, the law will promote illegal activities and legitimise the deforestation of thousands of hectares by agribusinesses. For his part, the environmental auditor Mauricio De Los Rios denounced the law as a “criminal” measure against the forest and its soils, demanding that it be repealed.
Stimulated by all these criticisms, Lucila Pautrat, a well-known forester and environmental defender, has presented a constitutional denunciation against the president of Congress, Alejandro Soto, for promulgating the law, arguing that it violates the constitutional protections of the environment and that irregular procedures were employed in its passage. This will be evaluated by the Sub-Commission for Constitutional Accusations of the Congress.
In addition, on 16 January, Congressman Edgard Mercado, in representation of the Cambio Democrático grouping, presented a legal project (6812/2023-CR) to have the law repealed.
Recent Comments