It has been a week of fierce infighting in and around the Public Prosecutor’s Office, the Ministerio Público. At the centre of the storm is Patricia Benavides, the chief public prosecutor, who at one is accused of being the leader of a criminal organisation and has, at the same time, launched a constitutional accusation against the president, Dina Boluarte.
Demonstrations were scheduled to take place this Saturday, 2 December, demanding Benavides’ removal. Further demonstrations are planned for 7, 8 and 9 December, the anniversary of Pedro Castillo’s ouster as president. Protests are likely to be strongest in the south of the country where some 50 people were killed in confrontations with the police and army, demonstrating over the way Castillo was removed and then imprisoned.
Investigations by the police and some public prosecutors suggest that Benavides acted illegally in using her influence to force out current members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (the entity responsible for appointing judges and the heads of the electoral authorities), the appointment of Josué Gutiérrez as ombudsman, and the move by Congress to disqualify her predecessor at the Ministerio Público, Zoraida Avalos. As the scandal against Benavides mounted, Gutiérrez suddenly skipped the country, travelling to Panama and then ostensibly to COP28.
Details of these manoeuvres were revealed on 27 November when recorded communications between Benavides and her chief advisor, Jaime Villanueva – known as ‘the philosopher’ – were made public. Villanueva and two others acted as intermediaries with Congress in pressing legislators to vote on matters of specific interest to Benavides in return for offers to let up on investigations into their affairs.
According to the transcripts, “the message is that we need to get rid of the caviar elite from all [these] institutions (…) while we are here the JNJ will not be taken over by Cerrón”. The term ‘caviar’ is taken to mean the leadership of the centre left.
The JNJ immediately opened disciplinary proceedings against Benavides. It has programmed a hearing for 6 December in which it will consider her suspension.
The Junta de Fiscales Supremas within the Ministerio Público has also called upon Benavides to resign so as not to obstruct ongoing investigations, with one of their members replacing her as chief prosecutor. José Domingo Pérez, the prosecutor at the heart of the enquiry into the Lava Jato corruption affair, who has come under direct attack from Benavides, has also demanded that she go.
Benavides has sought to fight back by appealing to the judiciary to prevent the case against her from proceeding. Earlier in the week she made clear she had no intention of going without a fight, lashing out with constitutional accusations (denuncias constitutcionales) against Boluarte, Prime Minister Alberto Otárola and three former ministers over their role in the killings last December and January.
She also took steps to sack the prosecutor, Marita Barreto, who was leading the enquiry into her alleged wrongdoing. Barreto, in turn, issued an appeal for protection from the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights.
As readers of the newsletter will recall, the Ministerio Público has been conducting an investigation – albeit at a snail’s pace – into responsibilities for the killings that took place. Boluarte was called upon to give evidence but failed to accept any personal responsibility, instead blaming security force officials. Benavides sought to claim that those involved “are people who are going to try to use all their power to block the course of justice”, to which Boluarte responded that this was just “a political manoeuvre” on Benavides’ part to protect herself.
Recent Comments