On 25 November, the Peru Support Group held its annual conference. Here there is a link to the conference for those readers unable to watch it live. The conference was followed by our AGM, a much shorter affair with a summary of the year’s main activities and a financial report. It is also available for viewing.
The conference focused on how the past bears on the present in Peru, and looked ahead to the main challenges and opportunities for us, as an advocacy and campaigning organisation in the UK. There was a panel of three speakers: John Crabtree, from Oxford University’s Latin American Centre and also chair of the PSG; Lord John Alderdice, member of the House of Lords, executive chair of the Changing Character of War Centre at Oxford University and also PSG president; and from Peru, we had one of the country’s foremost human rights advocates, sociologist Sofia Macher, formerly a member of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC).
John Crabtree noted that this year marks the 20th anniversary of the publication of the TRC’s report and thus provided an opportunity to reflect on the progress (or lack of it) in implementing its recommendations. This year also marks the 40th anniversary of the establishment of the Peru Support Group. But, as he stressed, “a human rights campaign should not have to last this long”. He outlined the current challenges that Peru faces, including the refusal of the current government to admit responsibility for the human rights violations committed during the mass protests of December 2022 and January 2023, resulting in the death of around 60 people. He highlighted the lack of credibility in the institutions governing the country, and the efforts by a right-wing majority in Congress to increase its control over the executive and judiciary. Foreign investment had been affected. Poverty levels are back to the high levels reached during the peak of the pandemic, resulting in growing income disparity and inequalities. In addition, he stressed how the effects of climate change were impacting on Peru through drought, water shortages, and the effects of El Niño, all of which could trigger further civil unrest. He concluded by saying that “the country deserves better, and we continue to do what we can to that end”.
Lord Alderdice continued by recounting the key findings of the visit to Peru in May this year, during which he and PSG Coordinator Ana Reyes-Hurt met with civil society organisations, UN agencies, people from the business sector, and senior government authorities. He said that it represented an opportunity to reflect on the progress of implementation of the TRC’s recommendations and to analyse current human rights, political and institutional problems. The PSG produced a report on the visit that analysed the progress achieved on those recommendations. In turn, it provided three recommendations of its own, including one relating to the importance of preserving memory in shaping societies and avoiding the mistakes of the past. “Forgetting about those who come from communities that are socially and economically marginalised is a recipe for long term instability in any country, not just in Peru”, he said, and “forgetting about past traumas is a serious mistake, because the consequences keep coming back, decade after decade, instead of disappearing, they actually become more difficult to resolve”. He concluded by saying: “remembering and resolving the problems of the past is not an option, it’s an essential task for any post-conflict society, and maintaining institutions that do remember and help people to remember those things is very important”.
Finally, Sofia Macher shared her reflexions about the TRC’s impact on democracy in Peru. She also talked about how the failure to address the TRC’s recommendations for institutional reform had repercussions today. She spoke about the Commission’s creation as an achievement in itself by recognising that what had happened to victims was a matter of public interest and the responsibility of the state. The TRC had allowed the history to be written by the victims themselves. This, Sofia noted, was unique in a country where history has been written by those in power. She spoke of the Commission’s success in providing a democratic space for the victims by means of public hearings, in which they could speak and provide their testimonies in their own language and process what had happened socially at the community level. Unfortunately, these spaces were closed with the end of the TRC, and their impact was perceived only locally. Sofia spoke of the Commission’s contribution to identifying the underlying causes of the violence and in giving specific recommendations to avoid these problems resurfacing.
Sofia then turned to the situation in Peru today, referring to the events that took place following Castillo’s ouster, when social protests were repressed by security forces without any state authority taking responsibility. Racism towards Quechua and Aymara speakers had been evident, she said, while protesters had been labelled as ‘terrorists’. These events showed that little had changed. Sofia then turned to the TRC recommendations still pending, including institutional reforms, reforms to the education system and to the justice system. These, she said, are crucial to guaranteeing the rule of law and the preservation of human rights and democracy. The recommendations outlined are not enumerated here, and readers can view them in the report she has recently produced with the Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos entitled ‘The Recommendations of the TRC 20 Years After’.
When asked what we can do to continue helping the work of human rights defenders in Peru, Sofia responded that international support is crucial, particularly in the current climate where authoritarianism seems to be taking hold. Particular elite interests were prevailing over the public good, she said, and there are genuine fears that future protests would be severely repressed. She claimed that what is taking place needs to be denounced. She concluded by saying that there needs “to be a channel that doesn’t allow for these things to happen”.
Recent Comments