Various US-based human rights organisations have issued a joint statement protesting against the suspension of Rafael Vela as the public prosecutor in charge of the Lava Jato investigations. As readers will recall, last month Vela was suspended for eight months and 15 days by the Autoridad Nacional de Control (ANC) of the Public Prosecutor’s Office (Ministerio Público) for what were termed “grave misdemeanours”. On 24 November, the suspension was upheld. He is appealing the ruling and pointing the finger at the chief public prosecutor, Patricia Benavides.

The ANC has also opened disciplinary proceedings against another key member of the Lava Jato team, José Domingo Pérez. Pérez vehemently denies the accusation that he made critical comments about Benavides.

Benavides has been criticised both within the legal community and without for lacking independence in her role. According to Antonio Maldonado, the prosecutor who attained the extradition of former president Alberto Fujimori, Benavides is involved in what he called “perverse alliances” that are undermining processes of “modernisation” within the Ministerio Público and leading to “absurd persecutions”.

The Center for Justice and International Law (CEJIL), the Due Process Foundation, the Robert F Kennedy Human Rights and the Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA) said that the proceedings initiated by the ANC against Vela were “summary and baseless”. They pointed to a “hostile climate” against those standing up for judicial independence, and that Vela and Pérez were faced with “disciplinary proceedings as a reprisal for their work in the struggle against corruption”.

Both Vela and Pérez were involved in the corruption investigation of various former presidents, including Alejandro Toledo and Pedro Pablo Kuczynski as well as the three-times presidential candidate Keiko Fujimori. Vela’s suspension means that he will no longer enjoy police protection. He has been the object of various threats. In 2021, Pérez called for a 30-year jail sentence for Keiko Fujimori for violating election funding rules in 2011 and 2016.

For his part, César Muñoz, the associate director for the Americas at Human Rights Watch, said that Vela’s suspension “undermines the struggle against corruption which in Peru is an enormous problem”. He sees this as part of a wider problem of “an attack against any democratic and independent institutions”, citing the attempt by Congress to remove the members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia instigated by the public prosecutor’s office.