The plenary session in Congress, which had been scheduled to debate and vote on the controversial recommendations of the Justice Commission to force the removal of members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia, resolved to postpone the proceedings on 8 November. This followed a judicial ruling (medida cautelar) that implied that the attempt by Congress to dismiss the current members of the JNJ lacked any juridical validity.
As readers of the PSG newsletter will be aware, the attempt by the far-right members of Congress, who form a majority in the Justice Commission, to get rid of the JNJ members has caused widespread indignation both at home and abroad. It poses a threat to Peru’s democratic institutions, specifically to the division of powers, since the JNJ is the body responsible for appointing and dismissing judges and the heads of Peru’s electoral authorities.
The judicial ruling effectively forced the Congress to halt proceedings. Even the day before, the president of Congress, Alejandro Soto, was rejecting the judicial ruling intimating he intended to push ahead regardless of the decision. But it appears to have dawned on the leaders of Congress that they were embarking on a potentially dangerous course.
According to one constitutional expert, if the Congress had decided to dismiss the JNJ members and had called on the executive to implement the measures, it would have led to a crisis of legality that would run a coach and horses through the rule of law. At the same time, legal experts, including the former Constitutional Tribunal (TC) judge, Marianella Ledesma, made clear that the TC would not be constitutionally entitled to nullify the medida cautelar.
Meanwhile, it remained doubtful whether sufficient members of Congress could be relied upon to ensure the required two-thirds majority to push ahead with the removal of the present JNJ. Previously, César Acuña, the leader of Alianza para el Progreso (APP), had made known his opposition to accepting the conclusions of the Justice Commission, thus casting doubt on the voting arithmetic.
The public prosecutor’s office (Ministerio Público) immediately responded by announcing an investigation into those judges who had backed the ruling. The leader of the team, Miguel Angel Vegas, is an appointee of the Chief Public Prosecutor, Patricia Benavides.
Recent Comments