A report recently published by the International Forestry Research Center (CIFOR) presents evidence that forestry conservation efforts in Peru in past decades have had little impact as high rates of deforestation continue.

The report claims that, despite having attracted millions of dollars to fund forest conservation initiatives, having created 254 public and private parks and protected areas, and having a series of international agreements and targets to protect forests, deforestation had increased by more than 326,000 acres per year since 2001. Forest loss peaked in 2020 at 502,000 acres of rainforest, equivalent to 379 football fields.

The study is based on a literature review of 17 studies which have evaluated the impact of conservation initiatives. These concluded that REDD+ mechanisms consistently performed poorly, having the least effect on both forest cover and in benefitting communities’ economic situation.

In general, the report argues that conservation projects in Peru have had at best a moderate effect on forest loss and often have had no effect at all. The impacts on the wellbeing of communities have ranged from positive to negative.

The authors of the report attribute these mediocre results to flaws in programme design, a failure to deliver on benefits promised to communities, deterring them from participating in conservation, and the location of projects being in areas facing little risk of deforestation.

They suggest that forest conservation initiatives could be much more effective if weak government forest monitoring systems are strengthened and if communication between academics who research and evaluate conservation programmes and the government agencies implementing them is improved.