Notwithstanding appeals by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights to respect the autonomy of the ombudsman’s office, Congress is pushing ahead speedily in the selection of a new Defensor del Pueblo. In its report, the IACHR urges Congress “to adopt measures to strengthen the Defensoría institutionally in view of the important tasks that it carries out” and urging it “to implement measures to ensure that the process of selecting a leader (…) is donr in a manner that is participative, transparent, pluralist and based on the merits and professional qualifications of aspirants”.

The process of selecting a new Defensor has, as we have repeatedly pointed out, been anything but regular and transparent. The process has had to be repeatedly aborted because of the failure to select someone with the qualities that the IACHR recommends. In a new attempt to choose a new Defensor, the special commission in Congress whose job this is has opted against holding an open selection.

Each of the party blocks in Congress has chosen its candidate. The list has been whittled down to three, of which the candidate of Podemos Perú (Pedro Cartolín) has now withdrawn from the race. The two who remain are Josue Gutiérrez (backed by Peru Libre) and Jorge Rioja (the candidate of Acción Popular). Each candidate has to be approved by two-thirds of the Congress, or 87 members. Rioja would seem to be the favourite given the majority of right-wing parties in the legislature. He is a conservative figure who has been highly critical of the IACHR in the past.

If neither candidate is chosen, then Congress will vote for one of the runners-up in the preselection process: Delia Muñoz (the candidate of Fuerza Popular) or Gastón Soto (Alianza por el Progreso). Both are noted conservatives.

Over the years, the Defensoría has been one of the institutions that has done most to protect human and civil rights in Peru. Its possible ‘capture’ by the hard right has many worried in the human rights community.

The final vote could come as soon as next week.