Alejandro Toledo’s return to Peru in handcuffs, extradited from the United States, brings to three the former presidents who today inhabit the Barbadillo prison in Ate on the outskirts of Peru’s capital. All three face accusations of corruption. Toledo’s extradition has revived discussion in the Peruvian media of the scale of corruption in public life, a discussion with a long history, a devastating present, and, in all probability, a durable future.
The first ex-president to be jailed at Barbadillo was Alberto Fujimori, president from 1990 to 2000. He was extradited from Chile, to be convicted in the Peruvian courts for corruption and the violation of human rights. Despite various attempts to wriggle free from his sentence, he remains a prisoner there. Toledo, elected president in 2001, shortly after Fujimori’s escape to Japan, was seen as the great hope for a return to democratic and ethical government. But as the evidence from the Lava Jato scandal was to show, he abused his position for the attractions of personal enrichment.
And so the story went on: Alan García (2006-11), who succeeded Toledo, committed suicide just as the police came to his door to arrest him for corruption. Ollanta Humala (2011-16) spent quite a long time in jail in preventative custody over charges of illicit election receipts in the 2006 and 2011 elections. Pedro Pablo Kuczynski (2016-18) has been under house-arrest over allegations of corruption in his capacity as Toledo’s minister of economy and finance, and Martín Vizcarra (2018-20) faces accusations of dirty dealing when governor of Moquegua, prior to becoming president. And Keiko Fujimori, who has three times got within an ace of the presidency, also stands charged with extensive corruption and, while not now in jail, has spent time there and is now under a restricted movement regime.
Is it surprising then that the ordinary Peruvian stands aghast at the foibles of Peru’s political class? In voting for Pedro Castillo and the left in 2021, they opted for what they thought was something completely different. Unfortunately, they were let down when it became clear that Castillo, the third inhabitant of Barbadillo, also appears to have abused the system to benefit himself and his friends. But it remains clear that the scale of any corruption benefitting Castillo’s friends and family was small when judged against the accusations levelled against most of his predecessors. Castillo’s impeachment and arrest on December 7, 2022, involved a strong dose of political vengeance on the part of his adversaries: Lima’s political and social elite who never fully accepted the presidential election victory of a humble schoolteacher from Cajamarca.
The history of corruption is a long one, as researched by Alfonso Quiroz in his pioneering book published in 2013 (well before the latest scandals broke). The patterns of corruption have changed over time, but the tentacles of corrupt influences penetrate the Peruvian state. Repeatedly, politicians seek election promising to root out corruption from public life; and repeatedly they become enmeshed in it, partly out of avarice but also because of the needs of those who seek protection from or preferential access to state decisions (not to mention contracts).
Toledo faces four separate charges: (i) money he received from Odebrecht for the contract to build the Interoceanic highway, sections 2 and 3; (ii) money he received via Ecoteva; (iii) money from Correa Camargo and others (Interoceanic Highway section 4); and money he received from the Olmos construction contract. The amounts involved exceed UD$35 million, money dedicated seemingly to personal enrichment. Toledo denies the charges against him, proclaiming himself innocent. But the evidence against him from both Odebrecht and Toledo’s business partner, Josef Maiman, looks strong.
Recent Comments