It was a week in which Peru came to Lima, demanding the closure of Congress and the resignation of Dina Boluarte as president. As thousands of protestors arrived in the city in the days leading up to the scheduled 19 January protest march, the streets became a battleground between them and the force of the state: some 12,000 police were deployed whose mission was to prevent them reaching either the Congress building or the government palace.
Demonstrations in Lima on 19 and 20 January, which suffered from a degree of disorganisation, coincided with further mobilisations of people in most major cities in Peru, combats with the riot police, attempts to occupy such strategic locations as airports in Cuzco, Juliaca and Arequipa, and the blocking of roads across the country.
The death toll has risen to at least 56 since the disturbances first began in December. No-one knows for sure how many people have been wounded in clashes with the security forces.
Without question, this display of popular anger on the streets of Lima and elsewhere is one of the largest in living memory, probably even greater than the national strikes of 1977 and 1978 which helped accelerate the restoration of democracy in 1980. The mobilisation was also reminiscent of the ‘Marcha de los Cuatro Suyos’ in 2000 when protestors from all over the country congregated to register their repudiation of the authoritarian regime of Alberto Fujimori.
One of the salient features of this mobilisation has been its fragmentation and lack of obvious leadership. This is, arguably, both a weakness and a strength: a weakness in the sense of lack of coordination and an overall strategic direction; a strength in the sense there is not an obvious person or group of people who can be picked off by the authorities. The degree of fragmentation also makes it very difficult for any negotiation to take place.
Responding to this new Marcha de los Cuatro Suyos and national strike, Boluarte addressed the nation on the evening of 19 January, offering little by way of any empathy or self-criticism. She described the protestors as “bad citizens who wish to break the rule of law, promote chaos, disorder and to take power”. She assured listeners that “the government stood firm” and that “the cabinet was more united than ever”. She made no mention of the new casualties. Previously, Boluarte had labelled the protestors as agitators and terrorists.
For their part, for those who had travelled to Lima from as far away as Puno (some 1,000 kms distant) there was no going back. They vowed to remain in Lima until such time as Boluarte resigns and the Congress is dissolved. The protests were sparked by the removal of Pedro Castillo as president and his subsequent imprisonment on 7 December. Despite inept policy decisions and allegations of corruption, Castillo retained the sympathy of the huge majorities who had voted for him in 2021 across rural Peru, especially in the south.
The Congress remains the focus for people’s anger. Dominated by parties of the far right, it is seen as the main obstacle to a political solution to the crisis. Its unpopularity is impressive; only 9% of people consulted in a poll by the Instituto de Estudios Peruanos (IEP) approve of the present Congress.
The president of Congress, José Williams, a retired general, has urged members of Congress to ratify in a second vote – due next month – the bringing forward of elections to April 2004. However, the demand has been building up for a much swifter electoral timetable. Members of Congress are seen as pushing for constitutional changes – the removal of the bar on immediate re-election and the restoration of the Senate – that would enable them to perpetuate themselves in office. Williams justifies the re-election of members of Congress as “It is obvious that a person who has exercised the role is going to have the experience to do better the next time”.
The demand for a Constituent Assembly to renew the 1993 constitution remains a key plank of opposition to the Boluarte government. But according to the constitution, this would require prior approval of the existing Congress which it shows no sign of giving. And, as the removal of Castillo showed, there is no way that the existing Congress can be constitutionally dissolved except when it refuses to grant the executive a vote of confidence on two separate occasions.
Predictably, the business community is viscerally opposed to the rewriting of the 1993 constitution whose aim it was to entrench the liberal economy and to remove the social objectives contained in the 1979 constitution. Roque Benavides, the mining magnate and former president of the Confiep business association, has written that “we do not need a new constitution, rather we can work on the basis of what we already have, and this would save us from what a Constituent Assembly would involve”. He went on “the constituent-lovers hide their real purpose which is to generate instability and a situation producing chaos (…) they are against the welfare that we want for Peru”.
The demand for immediate elections is also problematic in that, given the current rules of the game, a future election runs the risk of reproducing the existing Congress. A number of suggestions have been made over the years as to how this could be avoided, but the Congress – as currently constituted – has shown scant interest in pursuing these objectives.
Within this context of an atomised social movement and a far right entrenched in Congress and unwilling to cede ground, it is difficult to see how some sort of dialogue or negotiation can take place. The institutions of the central state – the executive, the Congress the judiciary and the armed forces – all align themselves against the protesters. There are institutions like the Defensoría del Pueblo, but it lacks the political clout to push forward an agenda of negotiation and reconciliation. The Catholic Church no longer seems an appropriate force for reconciliation. Maybe the answer lies in the recently elected provincial governors and their national association, but they too lack the political power to force a solution.
At its root, the problem is the lack of any sort of functioning representative institutions in today’s Peru through which ordinary people can interact on the wider political stage. As Ramón Pajuelo of the IEP has put it in a useful article, “Peru is a country in which the social and organisational fabric has frayed to the limit”.
Recent Comments