As the high-level delegation from the Organization of American States (OAS) descends on Lima, the Peruvian Congress is pushing ahead relentlessly with efforts to force President Pedro Castillo from office.
The delegation – which includes amongst others the foreign ministers of Argentina, Belize, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Guatemala – is scheduled to arrive on 20 November and stay until 23 November. During that time, it will interview top officials from the executive, legislature and judiciary. It will also try to talk to representatives from civil society, the Church, business organisations and trade unions.
It is unusual that such a large delegation of active foreign ministers, coupled also with some former ones, is deployed in this way. It seems to signify the importance attached by other countries in the hemisphere to propping up Peru’s apparently ailing democracy.
The purpose of the delegation is to listen to a variety of opinions and to offer help as to how the present political impasse can be resolved. According to the OAS press communique, “the group arrives in Peru to listen and to reflect on what it hears in its report (…) It is not travelling to back up the views of one or other parties, rather to produce a report on the situation”.
It was Castillo who, through Foreign Minister César Landa, requested that the OAS intercede in a situation that he characterised as a ‘coup’ in the making.
Since the OAS responded last month to this request, further pressure has built up in Congress which is seeking a variety of avenues to force Castillo out.
The Congress is considering a number of accusations in the form of a constitutional denunciation – some made by the chief public prosecutor, Patricia Benavides – that are likely to go before the plenary in the coming days. Whatever the merit of these accusations of malpractice and corruption – Castillo denies them – the opposition majority appears determined to push ahead with these proceedings.
Castillo’s defence here lies in Article 117 of the constitution which states that a sitting president can be investigated but not charged for crimes allegedly committed, until such time as he or she steps down from office. Article 117 spells out specifically a number of exceptions to this rule, but they do not include crimes of corruption. On 16 November, the Sub-commission for Constitutional Accusations (SAC) admitted for consideration Benavides’s list of charges.
Separately, the Congress is considering charges made against Castillo for treason, one of the exceptions specifically mentioned in Article 117. The accusation relates to an interview he gave to CNN in which he mentioned the possibility of ceding to Bolivia an access to the Pacific, subject to approval in a referendum. According to his lawyers, this cannot possibly be construed as an act of treason as there was no act involved, only an opinion.
Last week a majority in the SAC approved passing the case on to the Permanent Commission which must then decide whether to put the matter before the full Congress. A simple majority (66 votes out of 130) in the Congress would suffice to force Castillo out. Last week too, the Constitutional Tribunal held an audience in which Castillo’s lawyers appealed for a writ (amparo) to protect their client from the charges made.
Finally, in a third line of attack, Congresistas are once again seeking to amass sufficient signatures among members to push ahead with impeachment proceedings. This is their third attempt. Earlier attempts at the end of last year and the beginning of this failed to raise the necessary majority (87 votes). It seems unlikely that such a majority will be reached.
Adding to the climate of confrontation, on 17 November Prime Minister Aníbal Torres presented Congress with the challenge of a vote of confidence. This relates to the executive’s bill to repeal a law passed by Congress which restricted the grounds for holding a vote of confidence. By way of reprisal, Congress voted to refuse Castillo permission to travel to Mexico to attend the Pacific Alliance summit being held there. Where Congress fails to give a vote of confidence on two separate occasions in a five-year term, the executive can dissolve Congress.
The high-level delegation is thus entering a highly fraught situation which its decision to visit Peru has done little to attenuate. It will have to avoid appearing to take sides, but it will be difficult to offer an opinion without seeming to do so. Whether the parties in Congress who oppose Castillo will take any notice of what it suggests is unclear.
Probably the best that Castillo can expect is that the presence of the delegation, the writing of a report, and any eventual publication of an opinion by the OAS’s permanent council will take time to achieve. Meanwhile, the opposition parties may feel duty bound to suspend their efforts to oust Castillo. It may therefore be just an exercise in playing for time.
Recent Comments