In an historic ruling, the judiciary has ordered regional governments to abstain from granting logging concessions on indigenous reserves for peoples in voluntary isolation.

On 21 November the Superior Court of Loreto issued its decision regarding a claim presented by ORPIO, with support from the Legal Defence Institute (IDL), the Forest Peoples Programme (FPP) and the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA).

The court ordered the Loreto regional government to abstain from granting logging concessions in the territories of indigenous peoples in isolation. The sentence also prohibited the regional government from granting, reactivating, creating, establishing, or shaping forestry concessions within the Yavarí Tapiche, Yavarí Mirim, Napo Tigre or Sierra del Divisor Occidental indigenous reserves.

The ruling comes despite a media campaign by the logging industry, in an alliance with the Loreto regional government, that questions the very existence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. It also comes despite a bill before Congress that would transfer the authority to create indigenous reserves away from the national to the regional governments. Furthermore, it also comes in the context of renewed calls by indigenous organisations for the annulling of logging concessions that overlap with indigenous reserves.

This ruling not only formally recognises the existence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation but protects them from those seeking to eliminate the indigenous reserves. The Loreto regional government has decided not to appeal the decision.

As this newsletter has previously reported, there has been a long-running conflict between the logging industry and its allies in the Loreto regional government and in Congress on the one hand, and national and regional indigenous organisations and their allies in government on the other, over whether indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation exist at all; whether their traditional territories should be recognised and protected; and whether there should be any restrictions on logging concessions granted by regional governments in the Peruvian Amazon.

The conflict highlights the tension between the right of private businesses to exploit the region’s natural resources and the human rights of vulnerable peoples in voluntary isolation. It also highlights the defence of the rainforest against depredation with its consequences in accelerating global climate change.

Aidesep, the national indigenous organisation, and ORPIO, the Loreto regional organization, have sent open letters once again to the Loreto regional government and the national forestry and wildlife authority, Serfor, urging them to annul 47 illegal forestry concessions that overlap with territorial reserves for indigenous in voluntary isolation.

Meanwhile, on 11 November, a member of Keiko Fujimori’s Fuerza Popular party presented a proposed law in Congress that would transfer authority for creating indigenous reserves from the Ministry of Culture to regional governments. More specifically, the bill proposes that

  • the existence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and the creation of indigenous reserves should be ratified via regional ordinances rather than by government supreme decree;
  • the commission that governs this process should include representatives from the regions and should be presided over by the respective regional governments, not the Ministry of Culture;
  • regional governments should be allowed to create commissions to review existing reserves and decide on whether they should continue, be annulled, or be extended; and
  • all processes for the creation of reserves should be suspended until the proposed new law is passed.

Not surprisingly, both Aidesep and ORPIO are virulently opposed to the proposed new law, claiming that it would violate the rights of peoples in voluntary isolation protected by specific legislation and by international agreements such as Convention 169 of the International Labour Organisation, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, the American Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, and the right to free, prior and informed consent.

It remains to be seen whether this judicial decision will end the campaign to weaken or abolish indigenous reserves or persuade FP to withdraw its proposed law from Congress. It also remains to be seen whether the 47 illegal logging concessions on indigenous territories for peoples in voluntary isolation will be annulled.