It has been a week of rising tensions in the longstanding conflict between the Castillo government and the right-wing opposition in Congress, notwithstanding the imminent visit of the mission from the Organization of American States (precise date so far unclear).
On 10 November, supporters of President Pedro Castillo took to the streets of Lima and other cities to demand implementation of the government’s original programme and fresh legislative elections. The marches followed those of the previous weekend which demanded Castillo’s removal but not legislative elections. These marches were led by personalities such as APRA’s Jorge del Castillo and Lourdes Flores of the former PPC who had previously challenged the legitimacy of the 2021 presidential elections.
On 11 November, members of the congressional Sub-committee on Constitutional Accusations (SAC) voted to push ahead with suspending Castillo for ‘treason against the fatherland’ for supposedly offering Bolivia an access to the Pacific through Peruvian territory. They voted to do so by eleven votes to ten with the chair, Lady Camones, using her casting vote against Castillo. In an interview with CNN, Castillo had said that such a proposal would need to be subject to a referendum.
The plenary of Congress will have the last word, though it seems that the justification for such an accusation, to say the least, is on flimsy grounds. But these days it is political majorities that count, not the justifications for positions adopted. For many observers, the decision of the SAC may prove to be an ‘own goal’, particularly in view of the imminent arrival of the OAS delegation.
Castillo remains under attack by Congress for a range of accusations over alleged corruption. He is protected by Article 117 from such accusations being formally laid against him until such time as his term in office has expired. However, Article 117 explicitly excludes acts of treason from such protection.
At the same time, a third attempt to impeach Castillo is under way. Here, however, it seems doubtful that the necessary two-thirds of Congress would approve his removal. Two earlier attempts – in December 2021 and February 2022 – failed to attract sufficient votes.
On 11 November, the courts agreed to hearing a plea lodged by Castillo’s lawyers that seeks to end the denunciations against him as well as moves to impeach him. This does not mean that they will uphold the plea.
The week also saw the attempt of Prime Minister Aníbal Torres to force the legislature into a vote of no confidence in the administration. He did so claiming that the Congress had failed to respond to an earlier legislative initiative from the executive that aimed to nullify the procedures governing votes of no-confidence.
Under the 1993 constitution, the president can dissolve Congress if the latter votes more than once against a vote of confidence in the cabinet in a five-year presidential period. It was in this way that the then president, Martín Vizcarra, dissolved Congress in September 2019 and forced fresh legislative elections.
The current Congress passed a law (31355) that restricts the grounds for calling a vote of confidence. In April, the executive sent a bill to Congress to block Law 31355, but it has since been effectively ignored by the Constitutional Commission in Congress. Executive proposals for legislation are supposed to have priority over other business.
In his submission to Congress, Torres argued that Law 31355 seeks to “weaken the democratic system” by undercutting the constitutional powers of a “democratically elected president”.
The president of Congress, José Williams, responded by declaring Torres’ move inadmissible. Torres wrote back demanding that his request be reconsidered in the “first plenary session that is convened”, arguing his constitutional right to demand a vote of confidence. In a hastily convened emergency session, the Constitution Commission voted 6-9 to shelve the executive’s proposal without inviting Torres to substantiate it.
Recent Comments