It has been a week in which the operation of the justice system has come under close public scrutiny, in particular by the attempt of a member of the National Board of Justice (Junta Nacional de Justicia, JNJ) and others to push for the dismissal of the current president of the judiciary, Elvia Barrios. The motivation behind the attempt to remove Barrios from the Supreme Court is widely believed to be political.
However, in a surprising turn of events – and despite days of negative publicity – the JNJ decided on 28 October to exempt Barrios, along with Supreme Court Judge Javier Arévalo and the former chief public prosecutor Pablo Sánchez from having to undergo the process of ratification which they were due to face on 2 and 3 November. However, the charges made against them remain, and all three will face a hearing into alleged wrongdoing on 8 and 9 November.
If the charges against them are dropped, they will then still have to go through the process of ratification. Arévalo is a strong candidate to replace Barrios when her term of office ends next month. The move by the JNJ appears designed to assert its control over the Supreme Court at a time of considerably political instability.
The politicisation of the judiciary and judicialization of politics have become more pronounced in recent years. Many of the political confrontations now end up in the courts with prosecutors and judges often themselves subject to political pressures. The fate of President Pedro Castillo, who is the subject of various judicial investigations, is perhaps the most conspicuous example.
The JNJ is responsible for judicial appointments both in the public prosecution service and the courts. It came into being in 2019, replacing the National Magistrates Council (Consejo Nacional de la Magistratura, CNM) which had been at the heart of the Callao corruption scandal the year before. As we said at the time, the members of the JNJ, sworn in at the beginning of 2020, were a mixed bag, and the selection process was much criticised at the time.
Specifically, Barrios has come under attack by Guillermo Thornberry of the JNJ because, in 2015, her husband had a job in the National Electoral Court (Jurado Nacional de Elecciones, JNE). According to Law 30225, family members of those appointed to top positions within the state cannot be employed in public posts.
However, the Constitutional Tribunal in 2020 modified the application of this law, arguing that it violated people’s human rights and that the rules needed to be applied flexibly and only when there was clear evidence of a conflict of interest. According to Thornberry, Barrios should have denounced the fact that her husband – whom she divorced in 2015 – had been thus employed.
The case in point took place seven years ago. It was only in 2018 that any complaint was received, and the JNJ has done nothing about it until now.
Using similar arguments, Thornberry is also seeking to force the resignation of Arévalo and Sánchez. Arévalo’s brother and Sánchez’s son also worked in the JNE at the time. Arévalo would be a strong candidate to replace Barrios were she removed from office.
Sánchez, previously Fiscal de la Nación (2015-18), was at the heart of the investigations into the Lava Jato scandal and the moves to get convictions against both Ollanta Humala and Keiko Fujimori on their unregistered campaign contributions in the 2011 elections. These cases are due to come up shortly before the Supreme Court. He was also a key figure in the conviction of Alberto Fujimori and Vladimiro Montesinos.
In June, the JNJ chose six new members of the Supreme Court out of a total of fifteen. On 1 December, the Court will choose a new president of the judiciary when Barrios’s term expires. The six may act as a group when it comes to deciding the outcome of the election, increasing the chance that not only will Barrios be removed but also her likely successor. At the same time, until its decision on 28 October, the JNJ was due to ratify (or not) six of the nine older supreme court judges, including Barrios and Arévalo as well as Jorge Salas, the president of the JNE.
Parallel to this, on 25 October, the Supreme Court declared that an (unnamed) official from the public prosecutor’s office was seeking to intimidate and put pressure on the Court in ways that undermined its judicial independence. Sources indicated that these manoeuvres were being channelled through the JNJ.
The JNJ played a decisive role back in June in choosing Patricia Benavides as the new chief public prosecutor for the period 2022 to 2025. Benavides has since played a key role in the investigations into alleged corruption and other wrongdoing by President Pedro Castillo. On 11 October, she took the unprecedented step of constitutionally denouncing Castillo on charges of corruption and officially passing the charges to the Congress for a case to be presented against him.
This charge may be decided upon in Congress in the next few days leading, almost certainly, to a referral of the matter to the Constitutional Tribunal. The latter would have to decide whether a sitting president can be the subject of formal accusations. It is unclear whether the visit of a team from the Organization of American States will delay the process.
The removal of Sánchez from the Ministerio Público is thought likely to strengthen the power of Benavides within the institution. The removal of Salas would open up a space at the head of the JNE, and – depending on who would replace him – give weight to those that argue that he presided over a fraudulent election in 2021.
Recent Comments