If President Pedro Castillo wanted to mend fences with Congress through his annual Independence Day speech on 28 July, it could not have been further from the mark. His speech – a rather rambling account of advances made over his first year in office – ended in boos and whistles from his right-wing opponents just at the point at which he was urging the need for unity and collaboration.

His objective appears to have been to show how much has been achieved and that his government is in control of its agenda. Most of the speech was dedicated to an account, ministry by ministry, of schools built, roads repaired, investments made etc. It began with an attack on the media which Castillo characterised as deliberately falsifying the image they project. “The media” he said, “are determined to destabilise the government and are not interested in publicising [any of] its achievements”. Castillo went on to deny responsibility for the corrupt actions for which he is being currently investigated by the public prosecutor’s office (Ministerio Público). “They [the media] are going to tire of looking for proof because they are not going to find any”, he said.

Rather than seek vengeance against his opponents in Congress for the “blows” they had inflicted on him during his first year, he said he “would turn the other cheek” in his second year, “holding out a hand to them to work together to the benefit of the people”. His intention was to say clearly that he had no plans to resign despite the pressures building up on his administration. He did, however, acknowledge that he had made mistakes in some of his ministerial and other appointments over the last year.

In his speech, Castillo distanced himself from his former radical stance, adopting a much more orthodox and business-friendly tone. On mining he said, “we respect existing contracts, and we support sustainable mining activity and ‘multi-actor’ participation”. He continued, “here it is in the interests of everyone to support the development of the mining complex (clúster minero) in generating economic development in the regions of our country”. He went on to state that this year to May, mining had accounted for 64% of export income and that investment this year would be worth US$5.3 billion. Not a word about nationalisation.

In recent weeks Castillo has found himself under growing pressure surrounding his alleged role in corrupt dealings in the transport sector and in seeking to override institutional procedures for appointments in the military and police. His former secretary-general in the palace, in whose office US$20,000 was found in cash, reappeared this week following months in hiding. He reportedly wants to give evidence under a plea bargain arrangement under which he recounts what he knows in return for a lighter sentence.

As Congress reassembles for the next legislative period under a new presidency (see below) there will almost certainly be new attempts to impeach the president. But it is also likely that the parties that once made up Perú Libre will come together to block such a move. The impasse between the Congress and the executive is therefore likely to continue. One of Castillo’s strengths is the weakness of his opponents and the lack of any clear leadership among their ranks. The elections to the presidency of Congress showed this with no less than four groupings fighting to occupy the top table.

Meanwhile, Castillo’s speech served as a reminder of the policies which he espoused at the outset and the extent to which a transformative agenda has been side-lined. Three key areas stand out:

  1. Constitutional reform. When the Castillo government took office, this was one of the key planks in its agenda. Progress to this end has been virtually nil. The idea was to elect a constituent assembly to draft a new constitution to replace that of 1993, introduced by the Fujimori government to replace in turn the previous 1979 constitution. Many on the left and centre-left saw the 1993 constitution as underpinning the neoliberal economic model espoused by Fujimori at the expense of social rights. The idea was that a new document would recalibrate the balance between these two objectives. Conservatives in Congress made clear from the start that they would oppose this tooth and nail. They were supported in this by business lobbies. The Castillo administration responded by arguing that it would pursue this objective on a longer time horizon. Nevertheless, members of Congress have themselves sought to amend the constitution in several ways to give them more power – so far without much success.
  2. A second agrarian reform. Castillo’s electoral support was strongest among rural voters and in regions far from Lima. In a speech in Cuzco on 3 October last year, Castillo announced a six-point policy plan to boost small-scale agriculture. It made clear that a second agrarian reform would not seek to redistribute rural property, although the reconcentration of landownership (especially along the coast) has been marked. Rather, policy would seek to increase the productivity and profitability of small-scale and peasant agriculture, providing the inputs necessary to achieve these goals. Discussion of this agenda appears to have gone off the boil since Juntos por el Perú left the governing coalition at the beginning of the year.
  3. Tax reform. The need for a more progressive tax system with fewer fiscal loopholes was laid out when Pedro Francke was minister of economy and finance. Peru’s tax take has traditionally been among the lowest in Latin America. The ministry produced a policy blueprint for tax reform in October. Francke’s proposals were given enthusiastic support by the World Bank. Since his resignation in January and his replacement as minister by Oscar Graham, the impulse for reform has dissipated. Francke’s proposals were opposed by business interests, especially in the mining sector which seemed likely to be asked to pay more by way of tax.