María del Carmen Alva, the president of Congress, unleashed a storm of protest last week after comments she made to the effect that the armed forces were siding with Congress in seeking to remove Pedro Castillo from the presidency. She now faces an accusation of sedition, lodged on 8 June with the public prosecutor. The political temperature is fast rising as Castillo’s opponents look for ways to force him out.
In an audio recording, Alva said “[Pedro Castillo] is up to his neck in it (hasta la coronilla). He doesn’t want to come before Congress, he has no way of defending himself, he’s alone, he’s in the shit (está cagado). What he wants is for the people to kick us out, just like with [Manuel] Merino. Do you understand? Why did Merino resign [as president] if he was there constitutionally? Because of pressure from the street. They want to close down Congress because we are here. Previously the armed forces took photos of themselves with Vizcarra because they were with him. This time the armed forces are with us.”
Alva was referring to the way in which, in November 2020, Vizcarra was forced out of the presidency having been impeached, giving way to Merino, as president of the Congress, there being no vice-president. After five days of protests on the streets of Lima, Merino was forced to resign, giving way to Francisco Sagasti who took over pending last year’s elections. Like Merino, Alva belongs to the more conservative wing of Acción Popular. A report presented last week by Alejandro Cavero, a member of Congress for the far-right Avanza País, sought to exonerate Merino from all blame for the street violence that led to two deaths at the hands of the police.
Alva’s comments, which she says were taken out of context, have led to widespread criticism. Constitutional experts have argued that in invoking the support of the armed forces to remove a sitting president she was guilty of violating the constitution. She has proved a controversial (and confrontational) figure in the past. On a visit to Madrid last year, she railed against Castillo in the Spanish parliament. She was also the initiative behind at a meeting in a Miraflores hotel in which opposition leaders discussed how to get rid of Castillo.
Were Castillo to be forced out, he would constitutionally be replaced by Dina Boluarte who is the vice-president. If, for whatever reason, Boluarte failed to suceed, Alva – like Merino – would take over on an interim basis pending further elections. According to another audio recording, Alva believes that if new elections were to be held these would be for the president, not for Congress. This reading of the 1993 constitution is likely to prove highly controversial.
Separately, the Constitution Commission in Congress, led by the arch-Fujimorista Patricia Juárez, last week rushed through approval of a package of constitutional amendments designed (amongst other things) to enhance the powers of the legislature vis-à-vis the executive. As well as enabling a return to a two-chamber system (a suggestion rejected by a large margin in a referendum in 2019), the changes would enable Congress to launch constitutional accusations against the three electoral organisations (the JNE, ONPE and Reniec) and to select the Comptroller. Another change would be to permit the re-election of members of Congress (also voted against in the same referendum).
Far-right members of Congress are trying to launch constitutional accusations against the heads of the JNE and ONPE for their role in last year’s elections, won narrowly by Castillo at the expense of Keiko Fujimori. However, they are currently protected from such an accusation by Article 99 of the constitution.
The Constitutional Commission rushed through without deliberation no less than 53 constitutional changes, against protests from a minority group. The plan appears to be to present these amendments to the next plenary of Congress scheduled for 14-16 June. They would need the support of no less than 87 members of Congress. Watch this space.
Meanwhile a judge has issued a cautionary measure against Alva requiring her to suspend for the time being the election of a new ombudsman (defensor del pueblo). He did so in support of a plea lodged by the union at the Defensoría based on the lack of transparency in the selection of candidates. In response, on 8 June, the Constitution Commission approved a draft bill that would outlaw the use of cautionary measures by judicial authorities on matters pertaining to the Congress.
Alejandro Aguinaga, the former health minister under the Fujimori government, who authorised the plan to sterilise indigenous women in the 1990s and is now a member of Congress, called upon Congress to ignore the judicial ruling.
Recent Comments