Despite the creation last year of the country’s largest reserve for indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and initial contact and the renewal of the temporary government body charged with their protection for another twelve months, the level of protection for uncontacted peoples – even those in legally-established reserves – continues to be precarious. The lack of consistency between norms and measures on the part of state agencies debilitates effective protection.

The decision of the Ministry of Culture extends for a further year the life of the temporary working group for the protection of “uncontacted” peoples. This group was created in 2018 and comprises different state agencies, regional governments, and indigenous organisations. It was established to propose and promote both mechanisms and legal norms to protect the rights of uncontacted peoples, especially those residing in or moving through areas outside territorial and indigenous reserves.

One of the group’s crowning achievements was the creation last year of the 1.1 million hectare Yavari Tapiche Reserve for indigenous peoples in “isolation”, the country’s largest such reserve. However, as freelance journalist David Hill points out, although legislation from 2006 states that such reserves are intangible, the Loreto regional government has granted some ten logging concessions that overlap with approximately 18% of the reserve.

In January 2021, the Multisectoral Commission agreed that six of the concessions would be relocated, but this has not happened. National and regional indigenous organisations, the Ministry of Culture and the national ombudsman’s office (Defensoría del Pueblo) have pressured the regional government to annul the remaining four concessions, but to no avail.

The national forestry authority, Serfor, has also been under pressure to annul the four concessions under powers granted to it by legislation from 2017, as well as to redefine the so-called Permanent Production Forests where the regional government can grant logging concessions. These now cover roughly 21% of the reserve.