By ordering the Peruvian courts to allow national and international NGOs to assist peoples in voluntary isolation to defend their rights, the Inter American Human Rights Court (IACHR) undermines recent legislation – the Ley APCI – aimed at restricting the activities of NGOs in the defence of human and environmental rights.

In 2022, the International NGO Earth Rights International (ERI) and the indigenous federation (FENAMAD) presented a claim to the Inter-American Human Rights Commission against the Government of Peru for not protecting the rights of the Mashco Piro indigenous in voluntary isolation. This was admitted by the Court in 2024.

In the subsequent hearings the government argued that the recently passed APCI Law does not allow third parties, such as national or international NGOs, to support those suing the government. The law provides for fines up to $700,000 for those organisations that finance, advise or assist legal actions against the state.

In a decision, notified on 8 July, the Court ordered the state to guarantee that FENAMAD and ERI can freely undertake legal defence of the Mashco Piro indigenous in legal actions against the state. The decision, which was unanimous, recognises the serious risk that the APCI Law represents for human rights organisations and for those who seek justice in the face of serious human rights violations. The case also sets a precedent in protecting the physical and cultural survival of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. The Court’s resolution can be found here.

The Court has also ordered Peru to respect the right of Peruvian human rights organisations to represent victims of human rights violation despite the Ley APCI. The ruling referred concretely to Comisedh (Comisión de Derechos Humanos) and Aprodeh (Asociación Pro Derechos Humanos) to pursue the case of Georgina Gamboa against the Peruvian state.

Gamboa was the victim of sexual abuse at the hands of the armed forces in Ayacucho during the period of armed conflict in the 1980s and 1990s. The Court demanded that those representing Gamboa should “freely exercise their legal representation” (our translation) and that “they should not be exposed to any sort of reprisal for doing so, particularly those derived from the possible application of Articles 21 and 22 “ of the Ley APCI”. The ruling also said that application of the law “constitutes an indirect way of effecting [an eventual] reprisal to the legal representation of presumed victims” before the Court.

In another groundbreaking decision, on 29 May, in response to a Consultative Opinion presented by the Governments of Colombia and Chile, the Court expressly recognised the human right to a healthy climate, thus setting a new legal standard for the member states of the Inter-American System.

This ruling obliges member states to prevent irreversible environmental damage, mitigate greenhouse gas emissions, regulate corporate behaviour and guarantee citizen participation in the formulation of climate policies. The Court indicated that recognition of the rights of nature and the associated ecosystems is fundamental for the protection of their integrity and long-run functioning. It also lays the groundwork for climate governance with a human rights focus, requiring that states act urgently and with citizen participation in defending environmental and social justice.