A case before the Constitutional Tribunal provides an opportunity to resolve the conflict between gas exploitation and protection for indigenous peoples in isolation (PIACI) in the Urubamba valley in Cuzco. This relates to the overlap between Camisea gas concession 88 and the Kugapakori, Nahua and Nanti Territorial Reserve (RTKNN) for indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation and initial contact. Combined with the recent appointment of Rocilda Nunta, coordinator of the women’s programme of the national indigenous federation (AIDESEP), as vice-minister for indigenous peoples at the Ministry of Culture, this also promises to strengthen protection for PIACI.

On 22 November, a government commission will meet to consider proposals for recategorising the RTKNN territorial reserve as an indigenous reserve. This could weaken the current level of protection for the isolated peoples on the reserve because the legislation to protect indigenous people in voluntary isolation (No. 28736, promulgated in 2006) explicitly allows for oil, gas, logging and other economic activities on indigenous reserves, thus threatening the survival of PIACI.

The Ministry of Culture is obliged to emit a binding technical opinion over whether extraction activities can be undertaken in reserves containing people in isolation. The Ministry of Culture will thus have to define the categorisation of the RTKNN. The regional indigenous federation (COMARU), with support from AIDESEP and the Amazon-wide COICA federation, has presented proposals that would involve the suspension of any measure recategorising the RTKNN as an indigenous reserve until the appropriate safeguards and technical and legal guarantees have been established.

Consideration of these proposals provides an opportunity not only to clarify the situation of conflict in the RTKNN but also to strengthen the protection of indigenous peoples in isolation in general. This is because it would involve reconsideration of the 2006 legislation and the strengthening of the protection offered to PIACI in indigenous reserves. The newly appointed vice-minister will have the chance to use her position to strengthen to such protection.