On 18 November, the Inter-Faith Rainforest Initiative (IRI), the Amazonian Pact and MOCICC, a civil society coalition that seeks to challenge the effects of climate change, held a webinar on the results of COP26 and what it means for Peru. The webinar began by outlining the main outcomes from Glasgow and reflected on the achievements and shortcomings as well as the road ahead for Peru.

In her opening remarks, Laura Vargas, IRI coordinator, spoke about how we are at a point of no return, where the world leaders need to make clear, solid and major commitments, changing what she called the prevailing “predators’ logic”. She sees the climate crisis as an ethical one, demanding radical change.

Manuel Pulgar-Vidal, expert on climate change and former environment minister, explained how the COP summits have changed over time from being state-driven affairs to multi-actor spaces in which economic and social issues are part of the agenda and in which civil society and corporations play a bigger role. No-one now challenges the view that global warming needs to be kept to the 1.5 degrees threshold. But despite the rhetoric and the commitments made at Glasgow, none of the promises will be achieved without tangible and measurable policies; these have yet to be delivered.

The panellists agreed that the Glasgow Pact contains some achievements, such as the commitment to maintain the 1.5 degree threshold and the inclusion (for the first time) of fossil fuels in the text, coal specifically (although not hydrocarbons as yet). As Pulgar-Vidal pointed out, the devil is in the detail; countries need to adjust their Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) to deliver on these promises. It is hoped that COP27, to be held in Egypt next year, will deliver these.

One of the biggest criticisms remains the lack of clear and transparent pathways with effective monitoring instruments. Without clear and defined objectives, pledges will not be enough. With regard to coal, the biggest disappointment was the change in the wording of the final draft at the insistence of India and China to “phase down” coal instead of “phasing it out” completely. The panellists agreed that countries remain beholden to an economic model that depends on the use of fossil fuels and the extraction of natural, finite resources. They agreed that what is needed is a shift in the model, and in the way we live.

Romina Rivera, climate change coordinator for MOCICC, stressed that although the COP has become a multi-actor space, the negotiations are still carried out by “white men in suits and ties” with little effective participation by civil society but a bigger, more palpable role for corporations. Some said that COP26 looked more like Davos, the annual World Economic Forum in Switzerland. It was clear that many multinationals, including oil and mining companies, had a strong presence in Glasgow, pushing their own agendas and offering ‘greenwashing’ rhetoric.

Panellists agreed that there were two further achievements: the commitment to stop deforestation and the financial promises from Global North countries for adaptation and mitigation. On finance, the goal of reaching US$100 billion was not reached but the commitment to US$83 billion was made. How and when these funds will be made available remains uncertain, as is what countries will do to bridge the shortfall. For participants from the Global South, adaptation funds remain very small, a critical issue for countries already facing the consequences of ocean erosion, water scarcity and so on.

On forest preservation, Tabea Casique, Ashaninka indigenous leader and board member of AIDESEP, argued that the commitment to protect and preserve 80% of the Amazonia by 2050 is key, as is respect for and protection of indigenous territories and recognition of the role that indigenous people play in combatting climate change. Tabea spoke of the risks faced by indigenous communities in standing up against powerful economic interests. The growing number of killings of environmental defenders bears witness to this.

According to Ernesto Raez, director of the Instituto del Bien Común, one big omission from the Glasgow Pact was organised crime. He said that drug trafficking in Peru is gaining more and more ground in the Amazon forest, destroying communities and their livelihoods. He gave the example of a Catataibo community that now only occupies only 1% of its territory, having been squeezed out by cocaine traffickers. For Raez, the Ministry of Agriculture has conspicuously failed to ensure adaptation and protection.

Panellists welcomed the Declaration on Forest and Land Use, that vindicates the role of indigenous people in preserving the forest and the commitment “to working collectively to halt and reverse forest loss and land degradation by 2030 while delivering sustainable development and promoting an inclusive rural transformation”. But for this to work, Tabea explained, it is crucial that funds allocated to the preservation of the Amazon rainforest are funnelled through to the local communities. It is far from clear how these funds are going to be channelled and administered.

Beatriz Salazar, climate change coordinator at CEPES, spoke of the importance of ensuring that respect for human rights is central to mitigation and adaptation strategies and that local communities need to take ownership. It is crucial, she said, that more money is allocated to adaptation strategies to ensure food and water security. Human rights, she said, are missing from the wording of the Glasgow Pact and need to be included in future texts.

The panellists agreed that Peru remains far removed from realising the agenda outlined at COP26; the government has some short-term goals but no vision for the longer term, they said. Peru is dependent on fossil fuels and the current government appears unwilling to change this model. The government maintains a policy of pursuing and granting oil concessions, they said. For Pulgar-Vidal, Castillo’s failure to go to Glasgow was disappointing; he seems to lack a long-term vision with short-term considerations overshadowing all else.

Osver Polo, of MOCICC, ended saying that what Peru needs now is to lay down operational plans and a clearly defined pathway. Crucially, he said, there needs to be more citizen participation; the people need to take ownership and ensure compliance.