A new controversy has arisen presaging a battle between the executive and legislature. On 9 October, the congressional committee in Congress dealing with constitutional matters approved the text of a bill that would reduce the powers of a sitting president to dissolve Congress. The president of the committee is the fujimorista Patricia Juárez. The text will now be put before the plenary of Congress for its approval.
At the same time, the executive has produced a proposal which would possibly change the rules guiding the impeachment of a president as a counterpoint, arguing that the balance of power between executive and legislature needs to be preserved. The meeting between Mirtha Vásquez and María del Carmen Alva on 18 October may involve a discussion on this.
The opposition proposal has the enthusiastic backing of the right-wing parties in Congress: notably the trio of Renovación Popular, Fuerza Popular and Avanza País. It has been criticised by groups on the centre and the left who see this as yet another move to clip the wings of President Pedro Castillo and his cabinet.
Peru’s constitution, approved in 1993, involves a double lock. On the one hand, the executive can dissolve Congress and call new elections if, on two separate occasions within a five-year term, Congress refuses to pass a vote of confidence in the cabinet. At the same time, Congress has the power to impeach a president and force his or her resignation if a resolution to this end is passed by two-thirds of the members of the legislature.
The struggle for power between executive and legislature became clear when, in 2016, the executive failed to achieve a majority of members of Congress. In that year, the fujimorista Fuerza Popular won an absolute majority of seats, and it used this in the years that followed to harass the executive, first under the presidency of Pedro Pablo Kuczynski and then under that of Martín Vizcarra. Congress forced the resignation of Kuczynski in March 2018, avoiding his formal impeachment. Then, in the following year, Vizcarra used his presidential prerogative to dissolve Congress and call new elections.
In other words, what is basically a presidentialist system can easily be scuppered when the party in government lacks a majority in Congress or is unable to orchestrate a coalition that supports its legislative programme and prevent impeachment taking place.
As Rocío Silva Santisteban, a former member of Congress, explains “Our country is basically presidentialist in the sense that the person who governs is the president of the republic and not the ruling party. If we were in a parliamentary system we would do things differently. We [the legislature] would withdraw confidence [in the executive]. The majority in the Congress would have the power to do this”.
The bill proposed by the constitutional committee of Congress may well receive the support of Congress as a whole. If so, the executive is likely to declare the bill unconstitutional and refer it to a decision of the Constitutional Tribunal (TC), the entity charged with resolving disputes over what is constitutional and what is not.
However, the Congress has within its powers that of electing new members of the seven-member tribunal and is in the process of selecting replacements for six of them whose mandates have expired. It may be a largely new TC, reflecting the preferences of Congress, which ends up resolving this knotty constitutional issue. And, if finally passed, it would tilt the constitutional power further away from the executive.
Recent Comments